Was Anakin the right choice for Hayden.

I agree.

Hard to disagree with a sig....I mean point like that. 😛

pervert! ^ ^ ^ ^

Originally posted by Ast Rofan
Hard to disagree with a sig....I mean point like that. 😛

🙄

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
pervert! ^ ^ ^ ^

What? I still only have eyes for you JP. 😄

Originally posted by Lana
For one thing, I dunno how you think Anakin gave off any sort of 'feel' in the OT since Vader was Anakin in the OT for about 5 minutes, tops.....

For another, in the PT, of COURSE Anakin wasn't going to act like Vader. He didn't become Vader until the second half of ROTS. Even after that people whine that he didn't act like Vader....well, duh. He just became Vader. He didn't turn into the Vader we know from the OT overnight.

Apperance says everything, the original Anakin didnt look like a warior, he looked like an aged Jedi.

Yeah. Cos he was a ghost.

Let me ask you this. Did Obi-wan look much like a warrior in the OT? Not really. But was he in the PT? Yes.

Originally posted by Ast Rofan
Yeah, not many can stand and smile that good. 😛

JAJAJAJAJAJAJA 😆

I meant what he represents, what I always ask is why didnt they change sir Alec guiness too.

Originally posted by General Bondius
JAJAJAJAJAJAJA 😆

I meant what he represents, what I always ask is why didnt they change sir Alec guiness too.

The whole "Anakin died when he became Darth Vader" thing 🙄 Personally I disliked that change.

Originally posted by Lana
Yeah. Cos he was a ghost.

Let me ask you this. Did Obi-wan look much like a warrior in the OT? Not really. But was he in the PT? Yes.

An aged warrior, guy can move. Yeah, which brings me to another point, the little problems in Star Wars are what makes it priceless, ala Emperor being played by someone else in ESB.

If there are any problems in SW in regards to continuity, they were made by the PT, not the OT.

The Sidious thing in ESB is completely irrelevant.

I didnt say their was a problem of continunity in the OT.

I thought the Emperor was creepier in the original ESB...

I preferred Sebastian Shaw for the OT Anakin; otherwise, it looks like Anakin didn't age in the past 20+ years.

Originally posted by Captain REX
I thought the Emperor was creepier in the original ESB...

I preferred Sebastian Shaw for the OT Anakin; otherwise, it looks like Anakin didn't age in the past 20+ years.

No kidding. Which is blatantly obvious, when Luke removes Vader's mask, to not be the case.

I though Hayden was great but I must admit I would have loved to see *puts on kevlar vest* Leo DiCapprio playing him. I know people will strongly disagree but the boy can act. AND he looks like Jake Lloyd. A bit.

Originally posted by Captain REX
I thought the Emperor was creepier in the original ESB...

I preferred Sebastian Shaw for the OT Anakin; otherwise, it looks like Anakin didn't age in the past 20+ years.

Well, thats something we can agree on.

Lucas should have re-filmed the unmasking scene and had an aged Haydens face with the burns make up on. If he was gonna include him at the end then he should just have went the whole hog and put him in the most memorable scene.

I liked his performance, so yes.

I didn't, so no. 😛

Yuck! DeCaprio with a lightsaber? He'll prolly find the first chick he can and *Ahhem*. I liked Hayden, his attitude was perfect. The ROTJ thing, I think, was needed. When I saw Sebastian Shaw at the end of ROTJ, I'd look at him, then obi-wan, and think "He wouldn't have the physical prowress to fight obi-wan." But Hayden standing there, I'd think. "I could definitly see 'em duking it out."