Doomsday vs Hercules vs Gilgamesh

Originally posted by olympian
Totally forgot about him.

What do you call the one that nearly killed Supes again but was afraid of him in the end of the story? Superman # 175 i think.

That makes 3 versions they have the edge then. Against two.

okay so we got non sentient doomsday.....aka doomsday......aka the Armageddon creature.

jokerized doomsday....aka doomsday rex....

and then heroic doomsday.....(although supes just referred to him as doomsday)....

heroic dd has something I find peculiar about him....he retained his sentience..however he looks far more comparable to his classic self than dd-rex does....dd-rex's head was different looking than before as were his bone protrusions...heroic looked exactly like his classic self but without the eye cages.....

Originally posted by armandovalles
really? hes a hero? thats seems pretty stupid. What issue was it of Action Comics?

supes-"why are you of all people helping me?"

dd-"curiosity....emotions require exploration....besides...there's only one of you to kill"

there are about 5 or 6 really great quotes from that book...sorry man I don't know the issue number off the top of my head though..I think 845...wait...no...maybe...i don't know....sorry...

Thats it. Doomsday Rex.

So we agree, the "weaker" versions lose and the uber ones win.

well classic dd-wins
dd rex- loses.....BAD....
new heroic dd.....i don't know yet...he seemed to be fairing out much much better against those endless cogs than superman did....I mean hell he fought a single battle that lasted 100 years against a seemingly endless army of cogs......so I'm still debating that one....

dos dd though....you really think gilgamesh and herc are above supes in the strength department?

Gilgamesh wins, like someone else said, because of the Eternal powerset. He's basically indestructable, is at LEAST at Thor level strength, has some low level matter manipulation, and will never suffer from fatigue. Eventually, he'll realize pounding on DD isn't working and encase him in adamantium, or just turn him to dust, or some other matter manipulation feat.

"well classic dd-wins
dos dd though....you really think gilgamesh and herc are above supes in the strength department?"

DD classic= Dos Doomsday right?

And yes i do belive. Guys like immortal Herc, Thor and Savage Hulk are for me above the Byrne Superman. And lets not forget that this Superman won ultimely the first fight.

"Gilgamesh wins, like someone else said, because of the Eternal powerset. He's basically indestructable"

He proved at least to handle heat (dont recall if it was magic or just extreme) better than Thor. Experience wise hes even above Herc. (both in actual myth history and at Marvel).

His manipulaton matter powers will come in hand against the strongest versions of Doomsday but against the weakest, these two with theyr speed, durability, skill and strenght will take it.