Against Nadd, maybe a minute or two. I'm not underestimating him in the least, but. . . . here's how I can put it. Other than Obi-Wan vs. Anakin, what prequel duel lasted more than two minutes? And I mean a saber duel, not a Yoda/Sidious-esque fight? None. And of course, even now I think that Ulic could give Yoda a good fight, and even defeat Dooku. But I don't think he could stand up to Nadd or Sadow and come out on top.
Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Err...Nadd controlled and manipulated Exar until Exar found the amulet which made him powerful enough to destroy Nadd. Spirits can also be defeated or destroyed without the use of artifacts. Watch Jaden defeating Ragnos spirit or Lukes Padawans defeating Exars spirit.It doesn't pretty much not matter if people use lightsabers or Sith swords. The swords can also deflect blasters and they can deflect lightsaber hits.
Right You Got nadd With His Sword And Mastery Of the force
And you Got Exar With His mastery Of the Staff Saber and a good control of the force
1) exar made the satff meening nadd would be overwelmed by it
2)Exar Would slice his sword in 1/2
3) Exar Was only manipulated to a point, after exar left korrbin Exar was in total control of him self Aka: The reason he got captuerd. If nadd was in control of exar that wouldnt of happend
Originally posted by Darth Windu
And why does everyone think that a staff/dual-wielding style is unstoppable?
Same reason people think Vaapad is strong against dark siders... A brain bug. Brain bugs are when little ideas get caught in peoples' heads and they eventually grow into unfounded generalizations.
good thread by the way.
tough to call honestly, would be an interesting skirmish to say the least.
but i think it would fall to nadd and sadow. if i remember correctly kun confronted droma and they fought for quite a while with neither one showing weakness till ragnos appeared before them.
droma is great but i don't think he's as powerful as sadow was. maybe on par with sadow in terms of fighting abilities but certainly not on par with force abilities.
kun perhaps being stronger than nadd, however i doubt he could kill nadd faster than sadow could kill droma.
hence i'd have to agree that nadd and sadow take this. ulic is strong but not as strong as the others imo.
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
Same reason people think Vaapad is strong against dark siders... A brain bug. Brain bugs are when little ideas get caught in peoples' heads and they eventually grow into unfounded generalizations.
So true. Some of the people that keep saying the staff is so unbeatable should tape two swords together, and then go try to swing it. It's terribly unwieldly.
Dark Lord of Jawas
Registered: Feb 2005
Location: Myrtle Beach, SC.
Well, I know it doesn't mean much in the grand scheme of canon, but the description of Nadd's equipment mentions him destroying Naga Sadow... But still, Nadd had to be smart or damn strong to do so... Naga Sadow was pretty pimp.
hahaha wat a dork
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
Well, I know it doesn't mean much in the grand scheme of canon, but the description of Nadd's equipment mentions him destroying Naga Sadow... But still, Nadd had to be smart or damn strong to do so... Naga Sadow was pretty pimp.
That's what I'm saying, it's implied, but it could just well be Nadd tricking Sadow and stealing his stuff. As far as "destroying Naga Sadow," that may or may not mean actually defeating him and sending Sadow to Neverland.
Yeah, Sadow as pimp.
Originally posted by Illustrious
That's what I'm saying, it's implied, but it could just well be Nadd tricking Sadow and stealing his stuff. As far as "destroying Naga Sadow," that may or may not mean actually defeating him and sending Sadow to Neverland.Yeah, Sadow as pimp.
I doubt Nadd did it in a fair fight. Sadow was pretty old but pretty powerful at that time, while Nadd was a fledgling jedi.
Originally posted by Darth Abominus
curious,is there proof that nadd did kill sadow? i read in this thread that he did but looked on wikipedia it is said that he may have but this isn't fully clear if he did or didn't.
thanks.
i was actually the person who entered on wikipedia that it has not been confirmed. I made a thread on that a while ago and a few people agreed with me, and since it has not been proven, I addedi it. So yes, the answer is, Nadd did not definatly kill Sadow. In fact he probably didn't.
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
I doubt Nadd did it in a fair fight. Sadow was pretty old but pretty powerful at that time, while Nadd was a fledgling jedi.
Wasn't Sadow a spirit at the time that Nadd killed him? Perhaps I am wrong, but I checked and a few sites said that this was true, and that it happened about six centuries after Sadow came to power (admittedly they weren't official SW sites, but they seemed legitimate and there were several of them that said so). If this is true, then Sadow would be weaker than he was in his prime (this I assumed based on the Marka Ragnos and Exar Kun cases).