Maybe the curse didn't hit him . I t could have hit the locket instead , and the impact of that could have caused him to fall of the astronomy tower. Maybe he wasn't killed because of the curse , but because he fell off the astronomy tower . Snape intended to kill DD , but the locket prevented that , yet DD still died , from falling off the tower .
Does anyone understand what i'm saying ?
Originally posted by DarkC
A.)Snape said the incantation out loud
B.)He fell off the Astronomy tower, which is pretty damn high
So, Snape could very well have used an entirely different incantation under his breath, there were many references to this throughout the book... Rowling never makes pointless references 😄
DD may already have been feeling the effects of the Draught of Living Death, which I believe he drank from the basin in the cave. It is mentioned that he landed in a sleeping position... another reference which should not be ignored.
Have you read my theory? Hotsauce and I have been piecing things together... along with a few other people.
And yes, I also think there's a chance Snape's curse hit the locket in DD's pocket, causing the impact that shot him off the tower...
Well it looks like the debate has started alreayd!! May I add that I cried my eyes out when I finally finished it?? (4 1/2 hours personal best!)
I love the subject bout snape is he evil or not?!?! And we should definetly talk bout Malfoy!
What about Voldermorts obsession with all things to do with the hogwarts founders?
And i think it would be great to talk bout all the relationships that are developing!!
Yep, the Malfoy debate will be good, cause the others are in way a bit exosted, many thread opended already.
Or, what about:
-Who will be the next Headmaster or Headmistress in Hogwarts
-Will Ron die ?(Harry has been losing his best friends since book 5 onwards, so it might be Ron's time to go?)
- What will Harry do after the defeat of Voldermort?
- Who will lead the Order
Originally posted by Hermione202I get it. It is just that DD's ending sucked.
Maybe the curse didn't hit him . I t could have hit the locket instead , and the impact of that could have caused him to fall of the astronomy tower. Maybe he wasn't killed because of the curse , but because he fell off the astronomy tower . Snape intended to kill DD , but the locket prevented that , yet DD still died , from falling off the tower .Does anyone understand what i'm saying ?
Originally posted by Unicor777Mcgonnagal(sp?) is the next Headmistress, since she is Deputy Headmistress... also that she did take over the Headmaster/mistress room. I like the thing on Ron dying, sounds interesting. The thing with Harry doing after Voldemort should be saved for more till book 7 comes out. The last one I can't comment on much.
Yep, the Malfoy debate will be good, cause the others are in way a bit exosted, many thread opended already.Or, what about:
-Who will be the next Headmaster or Headmistress in Hogwarts
-Will Ron die ?(Harry has been losing his best friends since book 5 onwards, so it might be Ron's time to go?)
- What will Harry do after the defeat of Voldermort?
- Who will lead the Order
Originally posted by Unicor777
-Will Ron die ?(Harry has been losing his best friends since book 5 onwards, so it might be Ron's time to go?)
Maybe just a who will die thread would be better?
Originally posted by Unicor777
- Who will lead the Order
I wondered about this one myself...................... as far as I know the only surviving original members of the order are
-Dedaleus Diggle
-Sturgis Podmore
-Lupin
-Moody
-Possibly Abeforth dumbledore
-Elphias Doge
-Hagrid
Maybe Moody? He'd be the best choice I think.
I think most likely because the majority of people believe that Hogwarts will be playing a very insignificant role (if any) in Book 7 and therefore the headmasters room will be seen even less, therefore very little of Dumbledore shall be seen from that painting anyway, there HAS to be other pictures though right? I mean Dumbledore was the BEST wizard in the world! And to be truthful a painting dont compare in anyway with the real thing after all Jk said (somewhere) that a painting is just the personality of the wizard not an identical copy on a painting or something like that!!
I think that better than the who will die debate, would be a who will SURVIVE one!
Im sure there is going to be a lot of deaths in the last book. An both sides would take casualties, so thats a better debat topic, at least for me.
In the other side i would like to dabate about which one of the dead eaters will die, and wich ones would end in Azkaban
The Evil One