Double Agent

If you still belived Killing Dumbledore was not a plan here is proof that it was.

eeeehhh....i guess your link is not working.....

It's fairly obvious by now that Snape is a good guy. Let's not have another band of delusional people like the 'Harry really likes Hermione' nuts.

Originally posted by KMCF
If you still belived Killing Dumbledore was not a plan here is proof that it was.

WE are not DELUSIONAL ! AND I think Snape is EVIL !

I think he's, perhaps not 'good', but definitely trustworthy in the long run... ever heard of the ends justifying the means? By killing DD and cementing LV's trust in him, he's guaranteed his place as LV's most valued 'friend', if LV does indeed, have friends. From this vantage point Snape can more than make up for the death of DD by saving the entire wizarding population alongside Harry when the time is right. That double agent thing is totally spot on ✅

Originally posted by Hermione202
WE are not DELUSIONAL ! AND I think Snape is EVIL !

YOu really shouldn't post like that TheSun.........

You might want to cool it Sun...and people can believe what they want to believe. It can still happen...and Hermione, hate to go against you, but SNAPE is GOOD.

It can still happen...

Hah!

😆

Anyhoo. I think there's more to the Snape killing Dumbledore debacle than it seems. Dumbledore actually BEGGING for his life is completely out of character. And Dumbledore has already implied numerous times that his life is not important. Harry's is.

He'll probably pull a Gandalf in Book 7.

Originally posted by Saratn
You might want to cool it Sun...and people can believe what they want to believe. It can still happen...and Hermione, hate to go against you, but SNAPE is GOOD.

nope hmm hes bad .

sorry but i have to disagree. HE IS GOOD...END OF DISCUSSION!!!

😇

you HAVE to be evil to kill someone. there cant be a discussion there. its more wether DD is dead or not. honestly, i hate to say it but i think he is. his portrait was in the headmasters office. they saw his body. its over. and snape killed him.

you don't have to be evil to kill. Sirius was about to kill Wormtail, so he would have been evil then.

The sun is so much fun!!

still you have to REALLY mean it to kill someone. and that would A LOT of underlying anger from Snape towards Dumbledore.
and i think theres a reason Sirius didnt kill Wormtail in the book, besides the whole turning him in for the crime thing. maybe JK wanted to prove you do have to be evil to kill.

No, Snape wouldn't necessarily have to be evil or even mean... I trust implicitly in DD and I think Snape did too. Snape did as DD asked, and I give him credit for that.

Blah people cant stand the fact dumbledore is dead so be it my friends we had many many discussions about siriuis's 'death' just like these we are now having bout dumbledore

i cant stand it that he is dead. but i believe it. i think everyone who has died so far is dead and thats it. they wont come back. death is nothing different in the world of harry potter. when someones dead theyre dead.

^ well said 😄