Poll
18%
73%
9%
swan could win in hand on hand, but allie may take the overall match. there's not much between them skillwise also due to the fact neither had real dueling experience. here's some background.
the latter had healing abilities and was student to her aunt adi gallia, council member and one of the most powerful women in the order. however, swan had the benefit of being taught by both micah giiett and plo koon- members of the jedi council, so she's possibly more broadly trained.
stass allie was hastily installed on the jedi council to replace her cousin in the last years of the clone wars and only about a year after she attained her masterhood. she was also part of a small rare unit of jedi called the circle of healers and apprenticed barriss offee. stass allie could hold her own in battle and was involved in protecting palpatine in the coruscant invasion though she tired quickly and was incapacitated by a nearby explosion while shaak ti was unfazed. she arguably did not survive the jedi purge, her body was never recovered.
bultar swan had no such luck in reaching the rank of master though she was a distinguished, competent knight, surviving the purge. swan's cunning technique was to minimise her movements to draw her opponent closer and into false confidence, then she'd attack with devastating precision and often devastating results. her fighting skills were exemplary as she was able to disarm and overpower darth vader, though her hardwired strict beliefs in conforming to the jedi code in every situation gave her a blind spot to the possibility of betrayal within her own ranks -and the ability to see the point of view of others around her who were desperate, leading to her fatal surprise.