Who brought about sin in the world?

Who brought about sin in the world?

1. Man – Who disobeyed God.
2. Satan – Who rebelled against God long before man was created.
3. God – The all knowing, all power being who should have know that his creation would disobey of rebel.

the only being with the ability to do so, God of course

he created man and satan, therefore he created sin

of course, there is no God

Originally posted by masterbruce
the only being with the ability to do so, God of course

he created man and satan, therefore he created sin

of course, there is no God

Did you vote?

Strictly speaking, Satan brought "sin" into the World - yet in the Old Testament, it was Eve who actually fell to her temptations.

Are you talking aboot Sin in general which would lead to the answer of there is no Sin....Sin is an absolutely subjective Idea of Societies.....
Or are you talking aboot Sin in the Bible, which I believe would have been an invention of Men cause God gave them free will (if I see this work of fiction right)

Originally posted by Bardock42
Are you talking aboot Sin in general which would lead to the answer of there is no Sin....Sin is an absolutely subjective Idea of Societies.....
Or are you talking aboot Sin in the Bible, which I believe would have been an invention of Men cause God gave them free will (if I see this work of fiction right)

Hi Bardock42

The chose is yours, that's why I put other in there.

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
Hi Bardock42

The chose is yours, that's why I put other in there.

good....I answered both though.....

Sin is not a real thing...its an invention.....

There is no real sin...it is only labels we put on our actions..Choices that may have been better than others..Since I believe we are all part of "The One"...what ever it is...we are in fact responsible for our own actions...and what we create...

But according the scripture it would be either 1. or 2. depending on your belief....No church would ever pick 3........I voted for "Other"..

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
Who brought about sin in the world?

1. Man – Who disobeyed God.
2. Satan – Who rebelled against God long before man was created.
3. God – The all knowing, all power being who should have know that his creation would disobey of rebel.

Satan brought sin into existence, but Adam and Eve brought it on mankind. God knew sin would happen but He allowed Satan to choose whether or not to sin, just as He allowed mankind to choose. Both Satan and mankind were forewarned of the rewards of both good and evil. Actually, God does not force His way on man or Satan, but He does force man and spirit to choose which way they want to go.

If something like sin exist then man created it, we are responsible for our own actions, if we do something bad it is our fault not God´s fault or Satan´s or whatever other entity.

The real question is, what is sin?

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
Who brought about sin in the world?

1. Man – Who disobeyed God.
2. Satan – Who rebelled against God long before man was created.
3. God – The all knowing, all power being who should have know that his creation would disobey of rebel.

Well the first sin ever to be done would be that of Satan. The person (or shall I say people rather) to let sin enter the world were both man and women. Woman disobeyed God, and man was to prideful to turn to God for help, and thus too fell into the temptation and sinned. God can not create sin because He is all good, and sin is all evil. God created free-will, which is good. Yet Satan and Humans alike toopk that free-will and did wrong.

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
The real question is, what is sin?

Tis an offense against God that causes seperation, both on a physical and spiritual level.

Originally posted by AOR
Tis an offense against God that causes seperation, both on a physical and spiritual level.

You can't be separated from God. It is like trying to separate yourself from the air around you. Also, you can not offend God, that would make God a petty being.

Originally posted by Belegûr
Strictly speaking, Satan brought "sin" into the World - yet in the Old Testament, it was Eve who actually fell to her temptations.

I have to agree 🙂

If I believed the story I'd say God. He crated man. He created Satan. He knew what would happen. He put the pieces in place that allowed it to occur. And, after all, in terms of Christian doctrine nothing, not a thing, exists without God, God created all.

Thus he created a world were "sin" would be an integral part of humanity and faith, and if they truly do know everything, they knew precisely what they were doing, and what would happen - so I'd put the origin of sin with him/her/it.

[QUOTE You can't be separated from God. It is like trying to separate yourself from the air around you. Also, you can not offend God, that would make God a petty being.[/QUOTE]

A true God would be like that, though the Christian God can seem petty.