Battle of the Brutes

LS combat only:
Darth Bane versus Darth Sion versus Luke Skywalker versus Darth Vader

LS combat only? You mean lightside?

I don't get it...

LightSaber, sorry, should have made that clearer. Who'd win in a straight brawl, no force powers.

Luke? A brute?

Maybe Bane and Sion and Vader (Sion would take it), but Luke would be squashed.

I dont' think so. If Luke would give into the DS, he could EASILY smash Vader.

Originally posted by Captain REX
Luke? A brute?

Maybe Bane and Sion and Vader (Sion would take it), but Luke would be squashed.

I think it's not meant to be in terms of physical prowess, but rather of skills with a lightsaber alone. Perhaps I am wrong, though, sir. Or perhaps I am stating the obvious. In that case, forgive me, sir.

Well, what era is Luke? Is this suited or pre-suit Vader? And what battleground will there be?

While we're at it, why is Vader even in this line up?

Not sure.

If we're going physical prowess, Vader and Luke are out. Luke is not that buff, and Vader had all his muscles cooked and now everything is robotic or controlled by electrical implements of the suit.

If we're going lightsaber prowess, I could understand Vader and maybe NJO Luke...

Originally posted by Gryn Jabar
I dont' think so. If Luke would give into the DS, he could EASILY smash Vader.

Prowess??? whats that

Prowess means tip-top shape, the best of the best, stuff like that. Professionals have prowess.

ooo now i get it

Well, dude... Vader is already out classed by Sion and Bane.

yess he is

but will they kill each other first, or take out the others...

... You're hoping.

I've got my college fund ($.25) riding on the results of this, so of course!

Wealthy people always flaunt their money... Meh

LOL