Grade ATTACK OF THE CLONES

That's cool Dejio. When a Star Wars fan talks about how he's disspointed in the movie, thats one thing. Thats ok. Its those movie critics I cant handle ... cause most of them who dish it, don;t know nothing about SW, and don't understand what its about, so they really don;t have the right to say half the things they say.

10 out of 10!! 😄 🙂

Everytime Palpatine opened his mouth I was thinking...you are so full of crap and you are so good at it !!!

holy schmoly I'm looking forward to this! palpy is *the* man of good lines.

There's no question of his power. Its easy to see how he'll declare himself emporer and take over the army.

We should re-name this thread "Grade AOTC if you really liked it!" I suspect the full breadth of opinion is not reflected in that poll!

party-pooper

Grading it 9 is quite a bit high methinks. That's almost untoppable. I mean, 10 is perfect. Does any such film exist?
And for a lousy love story like this it doesn't deserve a nine. 7.5 would be my ideal choice.

watch it a second time queeq, it's much better then

I will. But I doubt the slumping of the story between the Coruscant chase and the Geonisis asteroid battle will go away by watching it again.

I suspect the full breadth of opinion is not reflected in that poll!

why not?

You're not exactly the world's greatest romantic, are u queeq ? 😉

😂 lol, well lets ask gundy!😄

The coruscant scene is my personal favorite action scene of all time,

Spoiler:
The way Anakin chops up those centipedes, and doesn't even slice the sheets!!

Originally posted by master harmax
You're not exactly the world's greatest romantic, are u queeq ? 😉

I like romance.... but not when it's done as crappy as this. The Scene in the meadow is ridiculous.... BS about democracy.... Sound of Music look, the totally awful scene at the fireplace... "You're in my very soul.... tormenting me...." -- uggghhh. My favourite and most moving love scene is by far the Love PLedge right before they ride into the arena.... Now THAT is romance....
Naboo scenes suck here.... and the CGI apple looks super fake when she bites it.

yeah that apple is bad. but the rest is good, goooood I tell you!🙂
don't you just love it when anakin falls down on the ground and padme comes rushing, but they end up on top of eachother. true romantic moments!😛 joking aside, I thought it was very entertaining in a cheesy way, naboo looked beautiful and so did the happy couple. and the fire-scene was good, for several reasons🙂

THey roll over and don't even kiss??? I mean.... come on. ESB was by far more romantic: less scenes but so much more effective.

well I had a smile on through all the love-scenes anyways.
sure they're not as 'natural' as in ESB, but there was an oddly satisfying thing about it.

I got a smile when Anakin got on the Shaak, I though I was watching a Disney movie.

That was sarcasm BTW.

🙂 well I think you're being overly negative, mister! hayden and natalie was a very sweet couple!