Rate the comic sig above you!

Started by Rewmac195 pages

Scary sig 8/10 😄

Originally posted by Dayscribe
Can we stop doing the
"please rate _______ sig please"

It's getting annoying.

I half-agree.
One thing that has been getting annoying is when people post "please rate _______ sig please", while ignoring the sig above them.
I dont think its too much trouble to add a rating to your post, especially if you want other people to rate yours.

^9.5, nice.

9.5

Originally posted by Rewmac
9/10 Very good sig...I see Digi is really a pro...Digi can you rate my new Cable sig?

Cool, but it kinda looks like you just applied some color changes to a pic from a comic. The text blends a little too well too. The color's fine, but a black border for it or something would do wonders.

7/10

And an 8 for TK...cool sig, but the render itself looks a bit fuzzy or something

9/10

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Cool, but it kinda looks like you just applied some color changes to a pic from a comic. The text blends a little too well too. The color's fine, but a black border for it or something would do wonders.

7/10

And an 8 for TK...cool sig, but the render itself looks a bit fuzzy or something

I messed 20 mins with each pic to render it...Then another 10 with the backround of then....Aaaahhh...And you poke my eye out with 7 🙁🙁🙁: 😮‍💨 😈 😄 😆

8.9912345678910

8.5. Reed is awesome.

9/10

Originally posted by Rewmac
I messed 20 mins with each pic to render it...Then another 10 with the backround of then....Aaaahhh...And you poke my eye out with 7 🙁🙁🙁: 😮‍💨 😈 😄 😆

lol. Sorry there. Just trying to be honest. It looks cool though, but I generally try to form my responses in this thread in the form of constructive criticism. So a lot of times it sounds more harsh than I really mean it.

🙂

...

I have a problem now. I have 2 cool sigs for the competition but I can only enter one. One is a funny animation that actually works pretty well as a polished product. The other isn't animation, but has a wicked-cool design and is as polished as any sig I've ever made. The animation is slightly less professional-looking, but has the animation to back it up.

I'd show them, but I think that's against the rules or something. ...but I probably won't be doing anything else with sigs until the competition's over in about a week.

😬

Originally posted by DigiMark007
lol. Sorry there. Just trying to be honest. It looks cool though, but I generally try to form my responses in this thread in the form of constructive criticism. So a lot of times it sounds more harsh than I really mean it.

🙂

...

I have a problem now. I have 2 cool sigs for the competition but I can only enter one. One is a funny animation that actually works pretty well as a polished product. The other isn't animation, but has a wicked-cool design and is as polished as any sig I've ever made. The animation is slightly less professional-looking, but has the animation to back it up.

I'd show them, but I think that's against the rules or something. ...but I probably won't be doing anything else with sigs until the competition's over in about a week.

😬


10 / 10, so freaken cool.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
lol. Sorry there. Just trying to be honest. It looks cool though, but I generally try to form my responses in this thread in the form of constructive criticism. So a lot of times it sounds more harsh than I really mean it.

🙂

...

I have a problem now. I have 2 cool sigs for the competition but I can only enter one. One is a funny animation that actually works pretty well as a polished product. The other isn't animation, but has a wicked-cool design and is as polished as any sig I've ever made. The animation is slightly less professional-looking, but has the animation to back it up.

I'd show them, but I think that's against the rules or something. ...but I probably won't be doing anything else with sigs until the competition's over in about a week.

😬

I'd go for the more polished, serious one. ✅

I was thinking of entering a joke sig, but I figured I'd be better off with a real attempt.

For Takion:

7/10

The render is too small, and it doesn't blend well with the background. The text is too bland and doesn't add much to the sig. Nice looking overall, though. 🙂

What do you guys think?

Originally posted by Rewmac
What do you guys think?

10/10

Really? Thanks...What is this everybody wearin' Civil War sigs?

Its the in thing at the mo 😄

10/10 ✅

9/10

8.5. If the render were brought a bit more to the right, it would be better.

9/10 nice worked out