Punisher VS. Bane

well he sounds like he is insecure about his sexuality...."ur gay...and lack basic common sense"????

as for the guns argument.... 😕

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Frankly this description of his grand elaborate plan doesn't make it sound all that impressive...

Why is Punisher assumed to be doing absolutely nothing during prep time?

it's much more impressive when you actually read the story..

No prep it's still obviously Punisher. Prep, I'm thinking double KO with prep. They both shoot each other to bits.

h2h?

Is there an h2h option? Edge to Bane.

oh woops...my mistake..it just say prep and no prep...in that case I agree...I just instantly thought h2h when it said nop prep followed up by all the discussion of h2h afterwards, my bad...in that case you're right IMO.

Originally posted by Nataku8188
You yourself have admitted to having little knowledge of the character.

How can you say something like that when you barely know anything about the guy?

Just want to know one thing, how much experience does Bane have, fighting, using weaponary, prep, ect...A ballpark estimate.

Bane wins, both times.
In No Man's Land, he was holding like a giant M60 [two handed mounted machine gun] with one hand, like a kids toy pistol.

jinzin, have i told you lately you're my favourite poster? here's to common sense and knowledge wining out over the evil forces of shouting arguments down and fanboyism. 🍺

oh, and great dd scan. i'll drink to that too! 🍺

No prep?
Punisher. So much of a gun-nut, even Charles Heston'd be afraid of him.

Prep?
Bane. If this guy can orchestrate Batman getting messed up, and come in with the coup de tat [or whatever], then he'd wear Punisher out then come in and finish him.

Originally posted by jgiant
Just want to know one thing, how much experience does Bane have, fighting, using weaponary, prep, ect...A ballpark estimate.

half a lifetime..he's in his 30's I believe..but he's profficient as the KG beast in every department as shown during their brief team-up...

KGbeast is basically russia's best assassin...played "the game" better than batman did.

Originally posted by leonidas
jinzin, have i told you lately you're my favourite poster? here's to common sense and knowledge wining out over the evil forces of shouting arguments down and fanboyism. 🍺

lol...high five buddy!

The question of who is tougher and who is smarter is completely ridiculous. The Punisher would dominate in a fight with Bane. If you have any doubts, read the graphic novel "Born" where the punisher is a soldier in vietnam, and survives his post being overrun, and then napalmed.

Of course, our pal Frank has lost fights, who hasn't. No one wants to read a comic book about a character that can't lose.

Good post Hartigan.

I never said there was a H2H option. Did I state such a thing in my opening thread? 📖... Nope...

Originally posted by Sentry
Marvel's bad a$$ or The guy who broke the Bats...

Who takes it?

2 Scenarios:

1. No prep.

2. Both have 2 days of prep.

Debate.

Do you guys see hand to hand? Nope.

How long did it take Bane to orchestrate breaking the Bats? 2 days? 1 day? A week? Took him awhile right?

Bane will easily beat Punisher? Nope. Can he beat Punisher? Yes. Can Punisher beat Bane? Yes. Punisher has fought heroes like Doc Samson, Spiderman, Wolverine, Captain America, and the Ghost Rider, all on the same level or stronger and more durable than Bane. He's taken out a ton of criminal syndicates and low level street villains all of which have taken permanent dirt naps.

Punisher 7 out of 10 No prep.

Tie With 2 days of prep.

Originally posted by Sentry
Good post Hartigan.

I never said there was a H2H option. Did I state such a thing in my opening thread? 📖... Nope...

Do you guys see hand to hand? Nope.

How long did it take Bane to orchestrate breaking the Bats? 2 days? 1 day? A week? Took him awhile right?

Bane will easily beat Punisher? Nope. Can he beat Punisher? Yes. Can Punisher beat Bane? Yes. Punisher has fought heroes like Doc Samson, Spiderman, Wolverine, Captain America, and the Ghost Rider, all on the same level or stronger and more durable than Bane. He's taken out a ton of criminal syndicates and low level street villains all of which have taken permanent dirt naps.

Punisher 7 out of 10 No prep.

Tie With 2 days of prep.

Bane is not the classic street level brick guy.
He possess enhanced strenght thanks to the Venom, but without it he's at the peak of the human physical condition and he's a master hth fighter and fireweapons user plus a great tactician.
Against a not enhanced Bane tough, I'll give it to Castle 8/10, his willpower, killer instinct and maniac mind make him too much to handle for Bane, Castle will run into his enemy even with the arms chopped off and tear apart his throat with his teeth.

<<Bane will easily beat Punisher? Nope. Can he beat Punisher? Yes. Can Punisher beat Bane? Yes. >>

that's what i was trying to say . . .