Magna Bodyguard vs. IG-88

Who would win between one of General Grievous's Magna Bodyguards and one of the IG-88's? Lets just say IG-88 A (the original IG-88).

Probably IG-88, he is a bounty hunter. Well trained atleast. He could shoot the magna bodyguards to dust.

True but IG-100s (Manga Droid) was trained by General Grievous to defeat all types of opponents. Plus we saw that they have some pretty good armor and they can continue fighting headless. I would have to say the IG-100 would win.

Yeah, if I could change my vote I would. But magna guards wouldn't kill IG-88 that easily.

I'm with ESB on this, if they have a chance against a Jedi (kinda) they could hold thier own against another Droid

IG-88 wins he has like 20 weopons some have to work

Originally posted by Jaster Mereel
I'm with ESB on this, if they have a chance against a Jedi (kinda) they could hold thier own against another Droid

Ah, but Jedi don't Pulse Cannons, do they? One blast ha sthe radius of a grenade. Basically melts anything robotic through extremely powerful electronic shockwaves. The MagnaGuard's owned.

Originally posted by Darth Faunus
Ah, but Jedi don't Pulse Cannons, do they? One blast ha sthe radius of a grenade. Basically melts anything robotic through extremely powerful electronic shockwaves. The MagnaGuard's owned.

Originally posted by Darth Faunus
Ah, but Jedi don't Pulse Cannons, do they? One blast ha sthe radius of a grenade. Basically melts anything robotic through extremely powerful electronic shockwaves. The MagnaGuard's owned.

True- but if they were at close range, they'd both be dead. From what I've gathered, the guard droids prefer melee so if they had time to get close, the other droid would wither have to switch to melee (smart decision) and most likely get owned or start shooting randomly.

They have vibro-weapons. Essentially the SW version of chainsaws. They'd probably cleave right into the Guards' staves.

But aren't 'vibro cutlasses' and stuff alot more fragile than other weapons?

IG-88 would definitely win. He has a better arsenal, better list of accomplishments, better technology and is somewhat developed as a character in the EU.

Point is, IG's only equal or superior in the droid world is HK-47. And of course, Artoo, but he's a God, so. . .

IG could waste the Guard from a range with either Pulse weapons, flame throwers, heavy rifles, etc. And from close range, he could simply use his best vibro weapons.

From close range the magna guards would probably winbecause their electrostaffs do have electricity at the end to tally destroy IG-88, but from long range, I agree with faunus, the IG-88 would waste them with his heavy rifles and flame throwers. Overall IG-88 takes this.

You do know flame throwers aren't effective from long range, correct?

So? They'd melt the MagnaGuard soon as it tries to close in. ANd from long range, there're always Pulse weapons and heavy rifle.

I know that, I was just pointing that out for future reference for him.

IG-88. no match. It'd be afight of seconds. G's bodyguard get's owned

ig-88 the magna gaurds would win in melee but ig-88 wouldn't allow the magna gaurd to get that close.

I agree with xxxpoppunker182, I put something similar to that in one of my previous posts.