Will Anakin Still Be A Jedi in Episode III?

But that would be punishing him. I'm just using that as an example.

But anyway, can you really see the Jedi kicking him out when they are in the middle of a war? They need all the help they can get.

there is no anger there is peace

goes directly against their code

Depends how strong their principles are. Asusming their rules are there for good reason.

Anyway, Anakin WANTING to be a Knight should make very little difference! If he wants it too much it could be a good reason to deny it to him.

indeed, I think Anakin feels being held back is a key here, also his great ego.
He might show his emotion to some of the council members or "worse" Palpatine..... and he takes the advantage of Anakin feelings to make Anakin more reluctant towards the JO, maybe even more egocentric and conceited. In other words turn him against the JO principles

hence "If you only knew the power of the dark side"?

Yoda specifically says : " Powerful Jedi he was " ... Obi Wan also specifically says that he was a great jedi, although I forget the exact words. And Luke ... " I am a jedi ... like my father before me "

Anakin at the end of episode 2 is not a Jedi yet ... still an apprentice ... he hasnt taken the trials yet. Therefore it stands to reason, that he WILL be shown as a jedi in Episode 3. And atleast in the beginning of the movie, I suppose some of his greatness as a Jedi and a starpilot, referred to in the PT will be shown. At least, I hope it will.

But he IS a Jedi in AOTC; a padawan is still a Jedi and he is referred to as a Jedi at several points in the movie.

The starpilot reference needs more work, though...

But u know, he wasnt a powerful great jedi yet ... not the way Yoda said he was.

Well, Yoda said he was a powerful Jedi, which is true, and Obi-Wan said he was a cunning warrior and a great star pilot... that's pretty much all that was said.

I agree we may well all have expected to see him being rather more senior but I suspect what we have seen won't be far off from what we get.

Which is not too much. I still say he whinestoo much.

Well, that at least inherits neatly into Luke...

I don't think the star pilot thing needs explained anymore than it has done. Winning the pod race and destroying the control ship was enough for me.

And remember, Obi-Wan doesn't know he blew up the control ship by accident. He didn't see what happened.

After the battle, Obi-Wan would have been told that this 9 year old kid destroyed it. That would have impressed him.

Definately.....
Master Harmax, who whines too much??? Luke? or Anakin? I think Luke whines ten times more then Anakin

nice one Ush

It's a close on Julie ... I found Anakin quite irritating in some places in Episode 2.

I thought he was perfect.

🙄 nobody's perfect.....and I do agree that Anakin did have his Whiny monents....

You are soo wrong.....I am perfect.

perfect smuck ...😄😄

That'll be Schmuck, you Schmuck.