October Debate Suggestions

Originally posted by DarkC
{{Final Jeopardy theme}}

Uh.......lessee......

How 'bout the final fate of each of the Trio of Fire?

Originally posted by Raven Guardia
I think he means Like where the lives will take them, what will happen etc. for example, after fighting the final war Hermione and Ron will realize they love each other and decide to get married or say Harry and Hermione will fall in love stuff like that. And if they will become Auroras and what lies ahead in their futures.

But me and the Phantom left, so now It's Hrmionie202, Miak, and Saratn.

Originally posted by The Phantom
occult? Do you mean a cult?

Taking the name like that is illigal since it was Pielover who made up the name, and me, him, and Hermione were the ones who started it. Also, they have no way to have a name like that, it doesnt match it.

Originally posted by Pielover666
What the hell does that have to do with HP?

;p

Hmmm. I was just pondering, and I wondered - Voldermort has seven horcruxs, some of which have been destroyed. BUT Voldermort only knows about ONE of those - his diary. Is it possible then that he might have made another to replace it? After all he has killed since returning, but the one that sticks in my mind is Amelia Bones. Seems significant somehow - perhaps her death helped him create another Horcrux.

And is it possible that a wizard could create more then seven horcruxs? Slughorn was horrified at the thought of more then one, but Voldermort went beyond that, so if he wanted could he make more (though that would mess with the whole mystical seven thing)

it should be:
Does dumbledore have a horcrux?

No, it should be: Does scurran not know that Dumbledore is dead? Sorry that was a cheap shot...

In all seriousness, it should be about the significance of Harry's eyes being green... Or has that already been a debate topic?

did ddor became a horcrux? was that the curse on the ring? could it be the reason for his death by snape? since snape was the only one aware of it? and didn't ddor and snape had an argument about something snape was asked to do but he didn't want to do it? could the task be killing ddor? sorry but his death is bugging me. oh and yes i agree with the other guy, did ddor have a horcrux? i don't think he was ever that dark.

Originally posted by Imperial_Samura
Hmmm. I was just pondering, and I wondered - Voldermort has seven horcruxs, some of which have been destroyed. BUT Voldermort only knows about ONE of those - his diary. Is it possible then that he might have made another to replace it? After all he has killed since returning, but the one that sticks in my mind is Amelia Bones. Seems significant somehow - perhaps her death helped him create another Horcrux.

And is it possible that a wizard could create more then seven horcruxs? Slughorn was horrified at the thought of more then one, but Voldermort went beyond that, so if he wanted could he make more (though that would mess with the whole mystical seven thing)

I don't think Voldemort's soul could be divided up any more than it already was, else he would have created more. I also don't think he can replace the diary because the piece of soul he used to create that horcrux is now dead.

...and how about for October debate: 'should Harry tell the Order of the Pheonix about the horcruxes?' or 'will the OOTP find out about the horcruxes?'

he should tell then he'll have more hope of locating the rest but DD told him not to tell anybody so he's most likely not going to

that would be a good debate

that's true

Thanks guys for the suggestions!