Magnito VS NJO luke

Originally posted by Darth Magnevus
also don't start with the force lighting thing, magneto could counter that simply by makeing the magnetic fieald around himself the same polerization as the lightning and deflect it

Force lightning ? I'm talking about one of Luke's unique abilities and this is "instakill" - he basically raises his hands, shoots that stuff off and you're dead when it hits you and this would give Magneto no reaction time to build a magnetic field around himself the same polerization.

And hell...Magneto's powers didn't stop Xavier from lobotomizing him via psyonic powers so why do people think he can "block" force attacks ? Lightning maybe since that is energy but a force chocke, mind affecting force abilities or an ordinary "force push" are most likely not "blockable" for him - and if Obi-Wan can force push General Grievous 10 or 20 metres high than NJO Luke might push Magneto right out of the atmosphere.

Not even mentioning that Luke can make himself invisible and simply stab Magneto with a lightsaber if he likes to do that...

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Force lightning ? I'm talking about one of Luke's unique abilities and this is "instakill" - he basically raises his hands, shoots that stuff off and you're dead when it hits you and this would give Magneto [b]no reaction time to build a magnetic field around himself the same polerization.

And hell...Magneto's powers didn't stop Xavier from lobotomizing him via psyonic powers so why do people think he can "block" force attacks ? Lightning maybe since that is energy but a force chocke, mind affecting force abilities or an ordinary "force push" are most likely not "blockable" for him - and if Obi-Wan can force push General Grievous 10 or 20 metres high than NJO Luke might push Magneto right out of the atmosphere.

Not even mentioning that Luke can make himself invisible and simply stab Magneto with a lightsaber if he likes to do that... [/B]

I could almost agree - begrudgingly or otherwise - except with the final part.

Magneto can detect metals and magnetic waves - and if NJO Luke could do it - I doubt it's anything close to Magneto. So, Magneto could feel the metallic saber, and if he couldn't rip it away - which I also have a hard time believing - he could perhaps get away before Luke could kill him.

Someone kill this thread...it has made to many friends into enemies...

Originally posted by Veneficus
Someone kill this thread...it has made to many friends into enemies...

Can't we all just....get along?

forget it Janus is right we cant compare these guys

Heres how the fight would go: They start then magneto's falls to the ground dead because Luke broke his bones, crushed his organs, and broke his spinal cord just by not even moving.

this thread was dead for a reason!

Rex is going to close this thread...

Magneto. Possible scenarios:

#1 - Magneto flips Lukes Lightsaber around in his own hands and slices him in half.

#2 - Magneto seals Luke in a chamber of metal on Coruscant, then slowly crushes him (Or quickly).

Your assuming that Luke will even give him the time to do such a thing.

*Luke uses force speed and rips through Magneto with his saber

*Luke opens a blackhole and chucks Magneto through it

*Luke uses an instakill and Magneto drops dead

Your very stupid, instead of listing unsupported scenario's (see how easy it was for me) provide backup and support for your argument.

lol. Since when can Luke open up a blackhole? I thought he could only manipulate them.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
lol. Since when can Luke open up a blackhole? I thought he could only manipulate them.

He cant, these Luke fanboys will pull all sorts of things out of their ass to win a debate. Luke never even manipulated a black hole, he manipulated an artificial vong black hole that was only as powerful as its reactor and so in no way comparable to a real black hole.

Ah. Dident know that.

Magneto's magnetic telekenisis is capped at 100,000 tons. Luke has demonstrated far greater telekenisis, including moving a black hole (Even a small one has incredibly high density and mass).

Basically, with Luke trumping Magneto's greatest and only ability, Ole' Magny doesn't have a prayer.

According to GV Luke only moved an artificial one. It's very possible that it does not have that great of a density and mass.

Possible... But it was a black hole. Each normal black hole is billions the mass of one Star. Black holes are described with infinite density....

Even if it is trillions of times smaller and weaker than a normal one, Magneto's greatest feat is put to shame.

Originally posted by Great Vengeance
He cant, these Luke fanboys will pull all sorts of things out of their ass to win a debate. Luke never even manipulated a black hole, he manipulated an artificial vong black hole that was only as powerful as its reactor and so in no way comparable to a real black hole.

Whoa, so i'm a Luke fanboy when ive been constantly arguing against Luke, way to be inconsistent.

Originally posted by Deception
Rex is going to close this thread...

And Magneto would win. 😐