Originally posted by Darth_Emodaswell first dont take this as me bashing you or your opinion on the matter cuz most times when people try to "correct" others on knowledge things end up being said that really shouldnt be said.
And yet Dooku still lost. The superiority of the form is irrelevant, Anakin was just more powerful.Why is this so debateable? Dooku's midicholorian count was nothing compared to Palpatine's, and Anakin even had more potential than Palps. I don't find it difficult to believe at all that Anakin surpassed Dooku in fighting strength by the time of RoTS. Best evidence for this - Anakin won.
Btw - Dooku was told to lose, not die. That is not a valid argument.
First off Anakin is not more powerful then Dooku. No Jedi in 3 yrs of war can surpass a 80 yr old jedi master with a wonderfully elegant mastery of makashi, which is the most powerful lightsaber form.
secondly Dooku was told to lose, this is a very valid arguement because when somebody is not trying and somebody else is, anything can happen. i dont think Dooku was taking the fight seriously enough in my opinion. But everybody knows had Dooku been trying it would have been Geonosis all over again.
heres is an example of a non valid-arguement: Anakin had war experience.
war experiece does not help you in a 2 on 1 or 1 on1 lightsaber duel.
third as far as lightsaber combat goes i dont see any noticeably different lightsaber forms other than Dooku's makashi: the way he swings, his stance, etc. but this is jus my opinion and what I see in the movies.
and as far as midichlorian count. we know almost nothing about them
so midichlorians dont justify a reason for him being stronger. there is no list of midichlorian counts for the jedi. and dont even mention SuperShadow.
To sum this up, Dooku did lose, but when someone is trying to kill you and your just toying with them anything can happen. Dooku clearly was not taking this battle seriously enough.
Count Dooku is far more superior in lightsaber combat and force mastery then Anakin is, and he is straight up smarter then he is too. thus Dooku is just a better jedi.
Im not bashing Anakin i like him alot, but Anakin is not better then dooku in any way as a jedi, and there is no evidence strong enough to prove otherwise.
IMO this battle was the duel of fates all over again. Dooku underestimated Anakin and ended up getting killed, Maul underestimated Obi-Wan and got killed.
so lets drop this arguement and get back to the WTF moments.