Originally posted by Tank115
Jk Has said the books are the seven years at hogwart if he doesn't return then there is no seventh book
Originally posted by Henrik1991
i dont think he comes back... i think the seventh' book is about him finding and destroying the Horcrux... i wouldn't suprice me if the last book was named: Harry Potter and the last Horcrux....
Go back to the chamber of secrets when riddle had the diary he says the reson he was out of the diary was that ginny transfored some of her into the diaryh and he began to transfore himself into her to control her. so what if ginny was one of the horcruxes. could she still have part of his soul in her
No, Harry is not a horcrux. LV set out to find and kill him because of the prophecy. He intended to kill Harry before they ever met. So if LV's whole intention with Harry was to kill him, then he would not have ever made him a horcrux. If Harry does end up being a horcrux, it's either a cheap cop-out or a major plot-hole.
harry cannot be a horcux... DD said himself that no part of LV could ever live inside harry. and if you ask me i would say a 7th of LV soul is part of LV.... but any one have any idea what the other horcuxes could be... for instance somthing from griffindore.... or somthing thet represents griffindor.... if you have any ideas pleas send me a pm.
Let's just do some Horcrux counting. We know that there must be 6 Horcruxes since Voldemort ripped his soul into 7 pieces and one piece is still in his body. Now what do we have:
1) His diary (destroyed)
2) Slytherin's ring (destroyed)
3) Slytherin's amulet (destroyed)
4) Ravenclaw's goblet (still missing)
5) something once belonged to Gryffindor (unknown)
6) something once belonged to Hufflepuff (unknown)
Harry can't be a Horcrux for 3 reasons:
a) He doesn't belong to one of that categories
b) LV created the Horcruxs before his fall meaning that they were already created before he tried to kill Harry for the first time.
c) A Horcrux can only be created if you want to do it and I'm pretty sure that Voldemort didn't want to make Harry a horcrux.
[c) A Horcrux can only be created if you want to do it and I'm pretty sure that Voldemort didn't want to make Harry a horcrux.]
thank you. and also the dark lord herd about the proficy and tried to get rid of harry... y would he want to put apart of himself inside of the thing he was trying to destroy...
Originally posted by Borbarad
Let's just do some Horcrux counting. We know that there must be 6 Horcruxes since Voldemort ripped his soul into 7 pieces and one piece is still in his body. Now what do we have:1) His diary (destroyed)
2) Slytherin's ring (destroyed)
3) Slytherin's amulet (destroyed)
4) Ravenclaw's goblet (still missing)
5) something once belonged to Gryffindor (unknown)
6) something once belonged to Hufflepuff (unknown)Harry can't be a Horcrux for 3 reasons:
his fall meaning that they were already created before he tried to kill Harry for the first time.
a) He doesn't belong to one of that categories
b) LV created the Horcruxs [b]before
c) A Horcrux can only be created if you want to do it and I'm pretty sure that Voldemort didn't want to make Harry a horcrux. [/B]
b) LV created the Horcruxs before his fall meaning that they were already created before he tried to kill Harry for the first time.
I think that LV planned himself to die, if he created those Horcruxes. if he planned himself to die from Harry then it seems likely that Voldemort will plan it all again. So therefore forcing both of them to die but Voldemort might create more horcruxes and seeing as Harry might of died then who will save the wizarding world.
Sorry if that didnt make sense, i tried to make it understandable for all of you.
so in order of which we believed to have exsisted and/or destroyed:
1) Slytherins Locket - RAB XX
2) Riddles Diary - Harry XX
3) Marvolos Ring - Dumbledore XX
4) Hufflepuffs Cup
5) Something of either Ravenclaw's of Gryfindor's
6) Nagini
7) Voldemort
Jk has already stated that the Sorting hat is not a Horcrux and i thought that the first time the sword came into existence was in book 2, thereby removing it as a possible horcrux, and in my humble opinion making Harry a horcrux doesn't add up and seems very insensible, how is Harry going to kill himself then kill Voldemort!?
Originally posted by air
so in order of which we believed to have exsisted and/or destroyed:
1) Slytherins Locket - RAB XX
2) Riddles Diary - Harry XX
3) Marvolos Ring - Dumbledore XX
4) Hufflepuffs Cup
5) Something of either Ravenclaw's of Gryfindor's
6) Nagini
7) VoldemortJk has already stated that the Sorting hat is not a Horcrux and i thought that the first time the sword came into existence was in book 2, thereby removing it as a possible horcrux, and in my humble opinion making Harry a horcrux doesn't add up and seems very insensible, how is Harry going to kill himself then kill Voldemort!?
Whoever said Gryffindor's sword only was created in book 2 is wrong! It was released from the hat in Book 2 but probably was from long before then, in fact belonging to Godrric himself but it was conceiled with a spell for some reason! Someone on p1 or 2 said harry is the only living horcrux:
1) He probably isn't a Horcrux!
2) Nagini was living, last I checked
3) Does this remind anyone of the 2nd susan cooper book, I think it was The Darkness Rising or something...