Hmm...well, it can be re-done, unless someone feels like finding the link to the other (in which case I'd be happy to merge the 2 threads).
A few will come on screaming against rational thought, saying that the Tick will win. I'm a huge Tick fanboy, but smart money is with the Hulk. Tick might be nearly as durable, and he's probably stronger than base-strength Hulk...but eventually Banner would get angry enough and knock his head off.
From Wikipedia.com:
His superpowers are nigh-invulnerability, which allows him to crash and bang about without injury, super strength, and something referred to as "drama power", or basically a tendency for the Tick's Powers to increase as the situation becomes more dramatic. His battle cry is "Spoon!"
So, during the course of this fight, I'm sure it would become qutie dramatic. Dramatic enough, in fact, for Tick's strength to increase even more, very much overpowering Hulk's tendency to increase his strength through anger.
Com'on, man. Tick wins.
SPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOON!!!