If you were Galactus who would you pick to be a Herald Superman or Thor

Debate.

Superman, easily

I would give him power cosmic, which enhances his already amazing abilities exponentially, and elminating his weaknesses to kryptonite and magic...Superman would easily be my strongest herald, far beyond what Surfer ever attained

I would garb him in a sleek black uniform witha red S and no cape

he would be a freaking cool-looking badass that would strike fear in all who dare oppose Galactus

Yeah but Thor is just as powerful durable and with that belt lifts twice as much as he usally does also he got the God Force power and God of Thunder Powers.

That's nice. It's just that Superman has far more versatility than Thor. Amplify that with the power cosmic, and you get Superman 1 Million times five.

What versatility?

Superspeed. Heat vision. Superbreath. Soul Vision. X-Ray vision...need I go on?

In a crossover, Superman was called something akin to The Kryptonian as a herald of Galactus. And he was MAD powerful

Not including the fact that supes would rather die than be a slave to anyone... 😛

Superman...

Intelligence: Above Normal (5/10)
Strength: Superhuman Class 100 (11/12)
Speed: Superhuman (6/10)
Flight Speed: Unrevealed, probably Escape Velocity (9/12)
Stamina: Godlike (9/10)
Durability: Metahuman (9/14)
Agility: Superhuman (6/7)
Reflexes: Superhuman (6/7)
Fighting Skills: Trained in Asgardian arts of war, highly skilled hand-to-hand combatant, proficient with most Asgardian weaponry, highly skilled in the use of his hammer
Special Skills/Abilities: Due to his life as Don Blake, Thor possesses considerable knowledge and expertise in medicine.
Superhuman physical powers: Aside from the above listed attributes, an extremely long life span and immunity to all Earthly diseases
Superhuman Mental Powers: Control over his hammer, Mjolnir. Although Thor traditionally employed Mjolnir to command the powers of the storm, he could also generate such power himself. As the Lord of Asgard, Thor possessed the Odinpower, which enabled him to tap into near-infinite resources of cosmic and mystical power

The Hammer is more then a match for heat vision Superbreath. Soul Vision. X-Ray vision

Thor is to skilled in fighting and has the Hammer he is immortal

Superman. Easily

Thor.

He has versability kind of the same the same way. And the firepower he brings to the table its higher and so its the experience.

Superman is more versatile than Thor? I would argue the opposite.

Thor's hammer has shown to be able to:

Teleport
Travel at FTL speeds
Manipulate Matter on a pretty large scale
Manipulate Time on a large scale
Create forceblasts
Control Cosmic/Earth Weather to a massive degree
Create Force Fields
Odin Force

A lot of other shit that really doesn't get used a lot, and that's just his hammer.

I'd much rather have Thor, because Thor would help close the gap on the magic weakness that all the heralds and Galactus himself has.

Strange & Surfer have shown how powerful you can be when you mix cosmic/magic together.

What if Kryptonian Genes and Power Cosmik ............ combine !!!!
What if Odin Force and Power Cosmik .................. combine !!!!

Hell, if I were Galan, Id make the two fight each other to death, take the winner as a herald !!!

Thor. Why? Thor could more easily come around to the idea that the destruction of these worlds was part of the order and destiny of the Universe. Each their own Ragnarok that could not be avoided. Thor would understand that Galactus is like a storm.

laminator, pretty good reason

Originally posted by long pig
Superman is more versatile than Thor? I would argue the opposite.

Thor's hammer has shown to be able to:

Teleport
Travel at FTL speeds
Manipulate Matter on a pretty large scale
Manipulate Time on a large scale
Create forceblasts
Control Cosmic/Earth Weather to a massive degree
Create Force Fields
Odin Force

A lot of other shit that really doesn't get used a lot, and that's just his hammer.

I'd much rather have Thor, because Thor would help close the gap on the magic weakness that all the heralds and Galactus himself has.

Strange & Surfer have shown how powerful you can be when you mix cosmic/magic together.

Agreed. Id rather give Thor the power cosmic. Having experience with wielding and manipulating cosmic energies already and with his own mystical abilities i just feel he would be a more powerful, more versatile herald. We've already seen Supes with the power cosmic (The Kryptonian) a cosmically enhanced Thor would no doubt be more impressive.

Originally posted by pr1983
Not including the fact that supes would rather die than be a slave to anyone... 😛

Superman...

Yeah...except for Brainiac, Poison Ivy, and whoever else tells him that he now is their slave.....still Superman...maybe he'd get cooler...who knows.

Thor definitely. This guy suffers from PIS more than The Flash and Green Lantern put together. If you actually look at his actual powerlist, half the people that give him trouble should be about 20 levels below him.

Did he not one time open a Time portal when Korvac tried to blow him away?