Magneto v Phoenix (his beaten her before) well a doppleganger has :)

I can hear someone typing lots 🙂

Still stands. No need for typing. You have no ground to stand on. Let all bear witness to the actions of a desperate man. Im sorry i hurt your pride mate. If i knew it would result in this then i would have tried my best to stop being so damn witty

Jean appearing in a coccon in 86 heralded the retcon. Which made Phoenix Force an entity unto itself and also shoved all accountability for the D'bari incident on to the Phoenix. This was needed for Jean a popular heroine of the time to appear with an untarnished rep in the new X Factor team. New Xmen however helped abolish that retcon by establishing the cocoon/egg as a part of the phoenix life cycle. It then went on to state that Jean has to die to be reborn. Therefore making phoenix and Jean once again one and the same.

Your attempt to catch me out has once again flopped. As stated in the very same issue, Jean was needed in another reality. As was established by the title to be reborn at the required point, Jean had to die. It is the way of the Phoenix. Be it through suicide or allowing the destruction of her physical body Jean was meant to die and would have achieved it through any means possible.

You merely witnessed a part of the phoenix life cycle. Good try. 😱 😂

If debating was about winning or losing you'd be licking your wounds right now and id be popping open the bubbly 😱 😂

Phoenix much like the X-men has become quite silly.

An urgent retcon back to previous and frankly sane power levels is required IMHO.

I was right lots of typing, mainly abuse 🙂

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Still stands. No need for typing. You have no ground to stand on. Let all bear witness to the actions of a desperate man. Im sorry i hurt your pride mate. If i knew it would result in this then i would have tried my best to stop being so damn witty

Jean appearing in a coccon in 86 heralded the retcon. Which made Phoenix Force an entity unto itself and also shoved all accountability for the D'bari incident on to the Phoenix. This was needed for Jean a popular heroine of the time to appear with an untarnished rep in the new X Factor team. New Xmen however helped abolish that retcon by establishing the cocoon/egg as a part of the phoenix life cycle. It then went on to state that Jean has to die to be reborn. Therefore making phoenix and Jean once again one and the same.

Your attempt to catch me out has once again flopped. As stated in the very same issue, Jean was needed in another reality. As was established by the title to be reborn at the required point, Jean had to die. It is the way of the Phoenix. Be it through suicide or allowing the destruction of her physical body Jean was meant to die and would have achieved it through any means possible.

You merely witnessed a part of the phoenix life cycle. Good try. 😱 😂

If debating was about winning or losing you'd be licking your wounds right now and id be popping open the bubbly 😱 😂

Why type abuse when a picture gets straight to the topic🙂

😂

Phoenix getting beaten again🙂

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Could someone explain this? I thought Phoenix was supposed to be all powerful?

No abuse. Just straight up gospel truth. Hallelujah!!:

Jean appearing in a coccon in 86 heralded the retcon. Which made Phoenix Force an entity unto itself and also shoved all accountability for the D'bari incident on to the Phoenix. This was needed for Jean a popular heroine of the time to appear with an untarnished rep in the new X Factor team. New Xmen however helped abolish that retcon by establishing the cocoon/egg as a part of the phoenix life cycle. It then went on to state that Jean has to die to be reborn. Therefore making phoenix and Jean once again one and the same.

Your attempt to catch me out has once again flopped. As stated in the very same issue, Jean was needed in another reality. As was established by the title to be reborn at the required point, Jean had to die. It is the way of the Phoenix. Be it through suicide or allowing the destruction of her physical body Jean was meant to die and would have achieved it through any means possible.

You merely witnessed a part of the phoenix life cycle. Good try. 😱 😂

If debating was about winning or losing you'd be licking your wounds right now and id be popping open the bubbly 😱 😂

Im still having trouble deciding, I need to see that pic one more time.

Originally posted by Onikirimaru
Im still having trouble deciding, I need to see that pic one more time.

ask and it shall be so Onikirimaru my friend, here is "The pic" props to Avalon of the wind for the scan 🙂

If Pheonix actually decides when to die, I dont think Pheonix is that type of chick that would have her last words be "Jgg"

Originally posted by Onikirimaru
If Pheonix actually decides when to die, I dont think Pheonix is that type of chick that would have her last words be "Jgg"

Excellent point my friend ✅

Originally posted by Onikirimaru
If Pheonix actually decides when to die, I dont think Pheonix is that type of chick that would have her last words be "Jgg"

Originally posted by 7PennyNightmare
Phoenix much like the X-men has become quite silly.

An urgent retcon back to previous and frankly sane power levels is required IMHO.

🥷

Originally posted by Creshosk
I don't see why not. . since it was a physical body that was dying, it might just make noise automatically.

I hear barrel scrapping 😄

Originally posted by yahman
I hear barrel scrapping 😄

And it smells oddly like jealousy too.

After this we see her holding the 616 universe. . . So yeah, she really didn't choose to die. 🙄

Originally posted by Creshosk
I smell denial.

And it smells oddly like jealousy too.

After this we see her holding the 616 universe. . . So yeah, she really didn't choose to die. 🙄

I smell 😱 "the picture"

"jgg" Phoenixes death rattle

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
I smell 😱 "the picture"

"jgg" Phoenixes death rattle

He has no counter, or other information so he shows off that one picture again.

I really need a scan of wolvie regenerating fro a drop of blood so I can do this whirly tactic too.

"A single drop of blood! Here's the picture:

*picture*"

Originally posted by Creshosk
And he just keeps proving me right. . .

He has no counter, or other information so he shows off that one picture again.

I really need a scan of wolvie regenerating fro a drop of blood so I can do this whirly tactic too.

"A single drop of blood! Here's the picture:

*picture*"

Who needs other imformation when you can clearly see Phoenix beaten murdered 🙂

"jgg"

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
Who needs other imformation when you can clearly see Phoenix beaten murdered 🙂

"jgg"

"What other information do you need when you can clearly see wolverine regenerating from a single drop of blood?" 😱

You do know what a plot device is right? 😉

"I don't care about anything other than that ****ing ***** dying."

😆

by the way I'm just typing in *s and not actually saying anything under there. 🙂

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
Who needs other imformation when you can clearly see Phoenix beaten murdered 🙂

"jgg"

LOL

Originally posted by Creshosk
"What other information do you need when you can clearly see wolverine regenerating from a single drop of blood?" 😱

You do know what a plot device is right? 😉

Sorry Wolverines not in this thread 🙂

heres Jean dying 🙂

do you think anyone will notice my new sig 🙂

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
Sorry Wolverines not in this thread 🙂

You know I compared your actions and statement to that of a fanboy. 🙂

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
heres Jean dying 🙂

do you think anyone will notice my new sig 🙂

"I don't care about facts, information, or logic, just that she dies."