Karnak vs Wolverine

Started by Creshosk2 pages

Originally posted by Khellendros
Actually, you'd just need to sufficiently dislocate one of the vertebrae. Like I say, the bones are tough, but everthing in between isn't.
As I said there have been several feats in 616 where had that been true, Wolverine would have lost something.

The thing is, this isn't true, not for Wolverine. In Wolverine: Snikt! his right arm was burned so badly only his adamantium bones remained; guess what? They were still linked together. Wolverine was still able to use his arm (even though he had to hold it with his left hand). If there is cartilage between his bones that can be severed, than it can also be burned away, and obviously thats not the case.

What about New X-Men, E is for Extinction? Nova burned off all the flesh on his right arm, and guess what? the arm bones were still linked together. They didn't collapse or fall off, which is what they would have done had there been connecting ligaments and cartilage.

How about Miller's Wolverine? When Shingen and Logan fight, Shingen aims a sword stroke at Logans' neck; I've been informed that it was later explained (whether by Miller or Claremont, I don't know) that it was an attack that was meant to sever Wolverine's head, by cutting inbetween the connecting bones; but since Wolverine's adamantium reinforces and links those bones, it couldn't cut through.

And lets not forget Blood Hungry.

The only times he has lost something were in alternate timelines that were divergent before Wolverine went into the WeaponX program and realities. . .

AOA is a divergent before the WX program and he lost his hand.

HOM is an alternate reality that's also not 616. . .

HOM .............

But whats the point of having bone arms, without muscles to move it ??

Originally posted by ImmortalOne
Just pull out his goddamn heart or lung !!!

Hush now young man, the grownups are talking.

Originally posted by Creshosk
As I said there have been several feats in 616 where had that been true, Wolverine would have lost something.

The only times he has lost something were in alternate timelines that were divergent before Wolverine went into the WeaponX program and realities. . .

AOA is a divergent before the WX program and he lost his hand.

HOM is an alternate reality that's also not 616. . .


And yet I've seen Elektra jamming sais into his shoulder joints. I'm not saying adamantium isn't an excellent shock absorber, because it apparently is, and possibly even acts as a heatsink. But I'm still not seeing why a well-placed blade wouldn't sever the cord.

Originally posted by Khellendros
Hush now young man, the grownups are talking.

And yet I've seen Elektra jamming sais into his shoulder joints. I'm not saying adamantium isn't an excellent shock absorber, because it apparently is, and possibly even acts as a heatsink. But I'm still not seeing why a well-placed blade wouldn't sever the cord.

Because it hasn't before.

You can see there is a gap in the shoulders. (sorta below the bone)

Other wise she peirced adamantium due to the way that the shoulder is a ball joint.

Every limb are ball joints !!!
Xept the neck !!!

Originally posted by ImmortalOne
Every limb are ball joints !!!
Xept the neck !!!
Not really. . the hand for example has three different types of joints.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Because it hasn't before.[/img]

Uh huh. So, just because something hasn't happened in comics, it's invalid? Going by that logic, this forum is all but pointless.

If your saying that this forum is pointless.... it iS !!!

But thats what makes it ........ what it is !!

Originally posted by Khellendros
Uh huh. So, just because something hasn't happened in comics, it's invalid? Going by that logic, this forum is all but pointless.
No,

Why can't Spiderman or wolverine beat galactus, well it hasn't happened in the comics. . . so there's no evidence to support the idea that it can despite trying. . .

Did you even read my earlier post that specifically mentions shingen?

Shingen aims a sword stroke at Logans' neck; I've been informed that it was later explained (whether by Miller or Claremont, I don't know) that it was an attack that was meant to sever Wolverine's head, by cutting inbetween the connecting bones; but since Wolverine's adamantium reinforces and links those bones, it couldn't cut through.

Stop blaming Achilles, he was killed with a cheap, sucker punch shot.

🥷