The Ultimate Weapon

Started by finti5 pages

Only the movies are canon

movies are more canon then radio drama who are more canon then novel, but novels ARE canon

I wonder if the Geonasians are destroyed by the Empire. Most likely.

Movies are the only thing canon, if the novels were to be canon then Obi wan and Owen Lars are brothers which they aint

Novels are semi-canon, which is to say they are right unless the movies contradict them.

as they have with Owen Lars

Apparently, yes.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
they are right unless the movies contradict them.

Like said, the movie contradicted that part of the novel!

I know!!!

that was aimed at finti

I take it Finti doesn't like EU. 🙄

No. Not in either form.

Novels are semi-canon, which is to say they are right unless the movies contradict them.
which again will say that the only thing canon is the movies 😉

BB I really gave EU a chance I read all the books up to the Black Fleet Crisis trilogy. Then the bookstore I used were unable to deliver Shield Of Lies. Anywys the books were kind of similare, always in deep trouble against a very mighty opponent and Luke came out as a "havent really got a clue wuss kind off a Jedi" So after 14 books I packed it in and really wasnt that bothered that I didnt purchase the BFC trilogy and new rebellion, even if they looked the most promiseing ones, maybe I go for them in the fall, maybe.

That's nice. But it doesn't mean you have to hate all EU.

I think the big problem is that it doesn't feel very SW-ish

Depends.

I thought Shadows of the Empire was good.

It is. I've played the video game too. Kinda boring though. It look cool on Gamecube.

jedi outcast is comming for gamecube, im really looking forward for it, and bounty hunter

Well either you like EU or you dont, it is no in between