Shawshank redemption? or the green mile?

2 very good films by Frank Darabont, and we dont give him credit where verdit is due. so i dedicate this thread to him.

and another say, I was watching shawshank, when heywood said "that man is crazier than a rat in a tin-shit house" I found that kind of ironic, becasue one of the main characters in green mile WAS a rat in a tin shit house.

i hafto say, the green mile brought me to tears.

so what do you guys think?

which one is better picture overall.

personally I cant decide.

shawshank easily

The Shawshank Redemption for me.

Originally posted by MildPossession
The Shawshank Redemption for me.

Shawshank is a classic

Shawshank is my all time fave film.

Green Mile has nothing on Shawshank. I consider it my 2nd favorite movie dealing a lot with jail behind American History X.

Shawshank was more "realistic"...though both King novels were superbly put on screen...

Shawshank, definitely.

Originally posted by draconigena
Shawshank, definitely.

Shawshank was way better. No comparison.

Definately Shawshank, it's one of the best prison movies

its a landslide

Of course, the answer is Shawshank! The Green Mile is a pile of fly-swarming, pseudo-religious hokum!

Shawshank Remption

Shawshank, although The Green Mile did cause me to shed a tear.

Shawshank ..... EASILY 😄

Shawshank by far....the Green Mile is decent....nice to watch and all...but Shawshank is just awesome......much better story too.....

They both are good. They both provide different perspectives, too.

Shawshank Redemption. Ass-rape is funny.

(Yes, I'm still in a very, very foul mood.)