Originally posted by tragic mulatto
Yep. Knux beat Sonic in SA1, so he would kill Shadow.
And Sonic defeated Knuckles in SA1 big deal. And you're going to say that Sonic got the Chaos Emeralds knocked out of him meaning he lost. That doesn't mean anything. Tails defeated Knuckles in SA1. Shadow defeated Sonic while fighting Diablon.
Shadow > Sonic > Knuckles
Now let's go to Sonic Battle. Sonic defeated Knuckles twice in Sonic Battle. Knuckles is strong but is very slow in that game where as Shadow can run circles and win.
My favorite character is Sonic. (Oh no! My name is Shadow x 20 and Sonic Team made a Shadow the Hedgehog game. That must mean Sonic Team is going to become Shadow Team)
Knuckles can not even touch Sonic and Shadow can move just as fast as Sonic. Shadow wins. (And by the way I have no black hedgehog in my sig, I have a silver hedgehog)