Good Game or Good Graphics?

Would you rather have
A.) A good game with crappy graphics
B.) A bad game with great graphics

Good game, that is all I care about, though having nice graphics is a plus.

good game with decent graphics is good enough for me.

Speaking as one who still plays the original Super Mario Bros., I prefer a good, fun game. Though I love good graphics, if they're just there to cover a crappy game, it's no good.

Apparently, Fahrenheit (Indigo Project) is a great example of a good game with crap graphics.

Good game easily. But you cant have a good game with horrible graphics. The graphics still have to be decent.

looks like its unanomous. people buy games for the game and not graphics.

gameplay 100%

Some of my favorite games have lame graphics.

Originally posted by BackFire
gameplay 100%

Some of my favorite games have lame graphics.

Good game obviously. But you act like the two things are mutually exclusive. Good graphics often contribute to what is a good game. Even those games that are considered "classics" tend to have good graphics for its time.

like FF7.

Good game before graphics, I found forexample spliter cell to be a very lame game, even tho it had neat graphics, on the other hand, I play Might Of Magic, and its by far better the game play and a good story is acturly what I care the most for

games with crappy graphics but are addicting as hell:

diablo 2
quake 2 & 3
rubies of eventide
darksun
jardinains
doom 1 & 2
zelda OoT
Conkers bad Fur day

i like good games(with amazing graphics)

There are so many PS2 games that have really bad game play, I can list only a hand full that have excellent game play...

1. PRIMAL
2. Defiance
3. Soul Reaver 2
4. Mortal Kombat V

There are more PS1 games that still rein against most PS2 games, especially racing car games. The last NFS game that was any good was NFS High Stakes, the rest that followed aren't very interesting and lack intelligence.

Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver is still my all time favorite walk-through.
The ideas and the different mixes of music scores for each realm was one of the best ideas in a game yet.

Soccer is a big problem on the current generation of consoles, ACTUA Soccer 3 is the best soccer game, another PS1 production, excellent game play, commentary is brilliant.

Great Games List:

Wild 9
Oddworld 1 & 2
Silent Hill
Need For Speed: High Stakes
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
PRIMAL
Defiance
Soul Reaver 2
Mortal Kombat V
Soviate Strike
Moprtal Kombat 4

Crappy game with good graphics for me. Holla.

graphics and sound are what makes a good game great.

I would say theres a mix...
on a scale...
70% gameplay
30% graphics

I don't see why people want FF7 remade... Its still a great game, I would only want a remake if they were going to add more gameplay... I don't want it if there just adding better graphics...
...otherwise why not remake all the clasics with better graphics??

good game good game didn't he do well...higher or lower that a 5

Originally posted by Hit_and_Miss
I would say theres a mix...
on a scale...
70% gameplay
30% graphics

I don't see why people want FF7 remade... Its still a great game, I would only want a remake if they were going to add more gameplay... I don't want it if there just adding better graphics...
...otherwise why not remake all the clasics with better graphics??

Good idea.

Why not indeed.

They already remade MGS for Gamecube; proof that old games remade new are a very good thing.