i know that the gl would be fairly useless in this fight, i have one of the marvel vs dcs where the surfer drops him in a page. although he says he regrets doing it and wishes they hadnt faught. so anyone around his level is going to be pretty useless here too, as it took little time and by the looks of it even less energy for the surfer to trash gl. im not sure about the others, but the surfer does control radiation, and kryptonite radiation hurts superman a great deal so i think he drops too. im not familiar with the other dc characters but with two of their members taken out by the surfer with little energy consumption id say marvel wins.