Superman vs. Hulk

Started by The Sorrow444 pages
The Sorrow Senior Member

Originally posted by abhilegend
As we're using a scene from Waid's comic, yes. Waid doesn't writes hulk with a HF.

Yeah, I'm sure having your brains hanging out of your head don't require healing too.

No, I'm not saying he was at a full strength. He was weakened after all. But to what degree?

We've been at this before bro. Hulk was most definitely KOED as seen with his eyes closed and reverting back to banner. That only happens when he gets KOED under Waid.

Its laughable to think getting KOED by a mountain exploding and Thor's lightning are considered low showings now. Pak has really spoiled you hulk fans.
Hulk isn't injured. Banner is. Learn to differentiate. And retardness doesn't makes Hulk weak. Never has. Savage hulk, Mindless Hulk, Bannerless Hulk and so on. Its a testimony to how ignorant are you to Hulk's history.


This isn't unprecedented.

Hulk has never bern able to completely heal when debris has been lodged in his brain such as when Apoc finally removed the shrapnel in his head or when a Doombot performed brain surgery on him, the wound was still there. In this case it was bullets, and this was explained in the issue itself. It stated the shooter needed practice before attempting to kill Banner or he would simply Hulk out like he has on previous occasions he's been shot - and heal from the wounds. There was also an instance Banner broke his own fingers to transform, and once he became the Hulk his fingers were healed so yes in fact Waid HAS displayed him healing.

We don't see Hulks eyes closed, we see a look of pain maybe but he isn't down long enough to tell before he transforms as Banner is standing up. You can't ko the Hulk, yet leave Banner standing that doesn't even make sense. As I said these aren't low showings and don't have any revelance in this thread anyway.

Superman is strong, hella strong - up there with the Hulk but that isn't going to be enough if Hulk is determined to take him out. Kal is also held back by his morals, more so than Hulk is and he isn't going to beat the strongest there is without giving 100% from the get-go.

The whole myth that Hulk needs to work his way up to get to Supermans level is laughable too.

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Originally posted by The Sorrow
This isn't unprecedented.
Really? Do tell.

Hulk has never bern able to completely heal when debris has been lodged in his brain such as when Apoc finally removed the shrapnel in his head or when a Doombot performed brain surgery on him, the wound was still there.
It wasn't about a shrapnel in the brain or cutting his head open. His brain was hanging down from his head. He has healed from such cases lke when he tore half his head open with his own hands. No such thing here. I'd ask you to provide a single HF feat from Waid's hulk.
In this case it was bullets, and this was explained in the issue itself.
Not really.
It stated the shooter needed practice before attempting to kill Banner or he would simply Hulk out like he has on previous occasions he's been shot - and heal from the wounds. There was also an instance Banner broke his own fingers to transform, and once he became the Hulk his fingers were healed so yes in fact Waid HAS displayed him healing.
Not that kind of healing where transforming from one to another heals a wound. That'd be saying Black Adam heals himself when he transforms into Teth Adam. Those are two different forms just like Banner and hulk.

We don't see Hulks eyes closed, we see a look of pain maybe but he isn't down long enough to tell before he transforms as Banner is standing up.
You must be blind if you think so.

Hulk is most definitely KOED there.

You can't ko the Hulk, yet leave Banner standing that doesn't even make sense. As I said these aren't low showings and don't have any revelance in this thread anyway.
Like I said we've been over this. Hulk was definitely knocked out there. He transformed back into Banner just after that.

Superman is strong, hella strong - up there with the Hulk but that isn't going to be enough if Hulk is determined to take him out.
He also has his speed and HV. Hulk could be determined as much as he wants, it wouldn't save him from getting pummeled.
Kal is also held back by his morals, more so than Hulk is and he isn't going to beat the strongest there is without giving 100% from the get-go.
Fun fact: DCnU Superman doesn't holds back as much as post crisis superman. He is going to punch and start heat visioning from the start. He also uses speedblitzing rather often.

The whole myth that Hulk needs to work his way up to get to Supermans level is laughable too.
Who said that? I certainly didn't. Asking "how" Superman is going to win is more lulzworthy than that though.

carver9 Senior Member
Originally posted by abhilegend
The wound is healed up. That's what weakened hulk, not banner's retardness. Savage hulk is a retard himself, how can Banner's retardness weaken him?

Show me where It was stated Hulk healed from this damage and provide a scan. I am asking you a simple question. Then you previously said that Hulk doesn't have his healing factor anymore. You are all over the place. Now again, since Hulk doesn't have his healing factor per your own words, how did he heal the damage?

carver9 Senior Member

ABHI, who has this version of Superman defeated to make you think he could take Hulk? It took both him and an amped Batman to take out Mongul and if you think Mongul is as strong as Hulk then you are half crazy.

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Originally posted by carver9
Show me where It was stated Hulk healed from this damage and provide a scan. I am asking you a simple question. Then you previously said that Hulk doesn't have his healing factor anymore. You are all over the place. Now again, since Hulk doesn't have his healing factor per your own words, how did he heal the damage?

facepalm

You want me to post the scene with Hulk's brains hanging out of his head and then weeks later them being healed up.

Originally posted by carver9
ABHI, who has this version of Superman defeated to make you think he could take Hulk? It took both him and an amped Batman to take out Mongul and if you think Mongul is as strong as Hulk then you are half crazy.

Well, Mongul is definitely stronger than Abomination who beat the shit out of hulk. And Superman could've killed him with a single punch when going all out.

This has been always your problem, you will randomly chose a character and declare Hulk is stronger than him. Why wouldn't be Mongul stronger than Hulk if it took Superman and amped Batman to take him out? Hulk has a dynamic strength factor, it doesn't means he starts stronger than everybody.

Also Superman is likely stronger than even WWH seeing how he almost cracked hemisphere while being weakened. Under the same writer.

w00t

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by abhilegend
facepalm

You want me to post the scene with Hulk's brains hanging out of his head and then weeks later them being healed up.
Well, Mongul is definitely stronger than Abomination who beat the shit out of hulk. And Superman could've killed him with a single punch when going all out.

This has been always your problem, you will randomly chose a character and declare Hulk is stronger than him. Why wouldn't be Mongul stronger than Hulk if it took Superman and amped Batman to take him out? Hulk has a dynamic strength factor, it doesn't means he starts stronger than everybody.

Also Superman is likely stronger than even WWH seeing how he almost cracked hemisphere while being weakened. Under the same writer.

w00t

I want you to post the scene where Hulk non Healing factor (per your own words) healed him up from the brain damage. This is simple. Him walking around doesn't mean he healed since it was stated while in Hulk form that he is weakened.

How strong is current Abomination? It really doesn't matter since Abomination snuck attacked a weakened Hulk.

Provide that scan where Superman actually achieved this because going by statements a weakened Hulk can turn planets to dust with his fist. Also, lol, that isn't a strength ft even if he achieved this. The guy is exploding from the inside out. Hulk footstep shook the eastern sea board (Q nd since we are using statements) and he would have cracked the planet in half if he took another one. Superman got a long way to go before getting on the level of Pak Hulk. Desperation my friend...desperation.

-Pr- Hey Yo!

Abhi and carver, that's warnings for both of you.

What happened to putting each other on ignore?

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Originally posted by -Pr-
Abhi and carver, that's warnings for both of you.

What happened to putting each other on ignore?


Ok, I ignore him again.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by -Pr-
Abhi and carver, that's warnings for both of you.

What happened to putting each other on ignore?

I have him on ignore...I'm kind of nosey and I click on his posts sometimes. Thanks for bringing me back to reality. I will ignore his posts from now on.

God Cloth Seiya Senior Member

Supes throws hulk at Carver

/thread

carver9 Senior Member

Lol.

Time Immemorial Restricted

Look like Superman has the votes, Superman wins.

guy222 With my gal

Never ending debate

AnimeDeadpool Junior Member

Hulk wins...

Prof. T.C McAbe Kryptonian Scientist

Superman won this, comics, votes, reason, writers etc.

StiltmanFTW CBvF
Originally posted by guy222
Never ending debate
BrolyBlack Restricted

Wow, is the the OG Superman vs Hulk thread?

cdtm Restricted

Superman won in every possible outlet. Wizard magazine, crossovers, board debates.

There's like two Hulk fans in the entire world keeping this "debate" going.

BrolyBlack Restricted

Carver is one of them

Quick Freeze GLC Memeber
Originally posted by BrolyBlack
Carver is one of them

AsianHulk is the other 🙂