Durge vs. General Grievous

General Grievous is better than Durge, according to me.

and according to how GG became the seperatist leader next to Dooku, by beating durge.

Grievous beat, but didn't kill, Durge and Ventress at the same time.

When?

It never really happened in a comic or book, but it was stated that it did happen. Although, I have something to point out. GG doesn't seem like the merciful type, so what I'm thinking is that the battle was a non-lethal one, and it was meant to be that way. So maybe if Durge and GG were trying to kill (instead of just defeat each other) than Durge has more of a chance. Maybe not though. GG could still win.

My vote was for the outcome of a deathmatch between the two.

Yeah, GG bea Durge and Asajj at the same time (which I fund dumb). Maybe neither of them are as strong as we think of GG can take out both of them at once.

Or maybe GG is stronger than we think.

no. this was before general grievous was crippled by mace windu.

Guys. For the last time. It was 'Star Wars Tales'. The same series where Han crashes into Earth, Chewie becomes 'Sasquatch' and Indiana Jones stumbles upon the wreck of the Falcon and Han's skeletal remains. You can't take it into any consideration in these threads. So Grievous never did beat Durge and Ventress simultaneously. Have a read on a realization of mine a couple of months back. A theory on the General's 'suckiness', and why it is not so.

"Well, according to Count Dooku in LOE, who is Grievous' saber mentor, the General is incredibly skilled. However, while scolding him for seeming imperfections in his fighting style, the Count states that Grievous' greatest weapon and ally in combat is the element of surprise, along with fear and confusion. Without it, he would be destroyed. Then, the Sith Lord proceeds to name a few Jedi who would destroy the General if he didn't use these to his advantage; Obi-Wan was one of these Jedi, along with Cin Drallig, Mace Windu, and Yoda. Anakin was not. This may merely be the result of Dooku's determination not to acknowledge Anakin's growing power, but whatever. Proceeding. . . .

So, on Hypori, when a Jedi was killed in a split second by a mechanical fiend dropping onto his skull, Masters Ki-Adi-Mundi and Shaak Ti were stunned and confused, along with the other Jedi. They had never seen or heard of such a creature, and as a result, were sufficiently astounded, enough to give the droid General a victory against five Jedi. The same thing happened in LOE (I know, I use it a lot) when the General moves to capture the Chancellor. He uses a dramatic entrance combined with half a dozen of his towering elites to strike fear into the hearts of everyone present, thus ensuring a victory born of deception.

Anyway, as you saw in ROTS, Grievous has not a single one of these advantages on his side. In fact, Obi-Wan has the advantage of surprise on his side, and although it does little to faze Grievous, it nullifies the General's advantages. It was only Grievous' arrogance and confidence that kept him in the duel. When he realized he had not a chance, and probably remembered Dooku's warning, he fled.

Hope that answers it sufficiently enough. Just a theory, but in my mind, a fitting one."

hystericalHAHAHAHA, are ou serious!? I have never read it.

Grievous' confidence is electronic.

Say what now? It's "electronic"?

He's a cyborg, not a robot.

But even as a cyborg, parts of his brain have been replaced with electronics.

Prove up or shut up.

Agreed. Preferably the latter.

Right. But still, he can't be considered a Sith.

Everyone knew that. Are you captain Obvious?

Please tell me what other non-Force-sensitive persons can wield a lightsaber.

Han Solo. Ulic Qel-Droma.