Well I'd say that KOTOR's a better game, well thats my opinion, but because thats an RPG less people will enjoy it, while Battlefront wasn't as good but was easier to just set up and play, and theres more competition for games like that on PS2, and such...plus its like the only good game featuring stuff from the OT!
Originally posted by SS_181st_Snow
Nac, my bro, people parade new games all the time. Especially when one has the name "Star Wars" on it. If George Lucas made bottles of ketchup with Vader's face on them, you know how many people would camp out at the store until the ketchup arrived?
Originally posted by Ushgarak
But to answer your question? Because Battlefront is an on-line game, and they get buzz these days.
Well...I've always thought they should have given KotoR a multiplayer modus or at least a co-op mode.
@Nactous:
KotoR isn't the only SW game that ever got a GotY award. KotoR has won the GOTY awards for best character / story development, RPG of the year and best console playing game but have a look at the competition...
Compare that to other SW games that reached the GOTY finals:
1998: Jedi Knight (lost to Quake II in "Best Action Game" category and "Starcraft" in the best PC game category)
1999: Roque Squadron (N64 - lost against "Zelda: Ocarina of Time" in some categories like Game of the Year), in the same year Lucas Arts "Grim Fandango" won the Computer Adventure Game of the year award and was nominated in other categories (Graphic, Sound, Character / story development, Game of the Year). And Lucas Arts had other things running (DroidWorks, Beyond the magic)
2000:
Episode I Races - won "Best console racing game of the year" Award
X-Wing Alliance - lost in the "simulation" category against Microsoft Flight Simulator 2000
2002:
Jedi Knight II - lost against GTA 3 in the Action Category
And notice that the GotY was first awarded in 1998 when many SW "classics" were already released:
- Dark Forces
- Rebel Assault I and II
- X-Wing / TIE-Fighter
Had Lucas Arts ever released an SW Adventure game it would have pretty much owned the GotY Awards.
Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Well...I've always thought they should have given KotoR a multiplayer modus or at least a co-op mode.@Nactous:
KotoR isn't the only SW game that ever got a GotY award. KotoR has won the GOTY awards for best character / story development, RPG of the year and best console playing game but have a look at the competition...Compare that to other SW games that reached the GOTY finals:
1998: Jedi Knight (lost to Quake II in "Best Action Game" category and "Starcraft" in the best PC game category)
1999: Roque Squadron (N64 - lost against "Zelda: Ocarina of Time" in some categories like Game of the Year), in the same year Lucas Arts "Grim Fandango" won the Computer Adventure Game of the year award and was nominated in other categories (Graphic, Sound, Character / story development, Game of the Year). And Lucas Arts had other things running (DroidWorks, Beyond the magic)
2000:
Episode I Races - won "Best console racing game of the year" Award
X-Wing Alliance - lost in the "simulation" category against Microsoft Flight Simulator 20002002:
Jedi Knight II - lost against GTA 3 in the Action CategoryAnd notice that the GotY was first awarded in 1998 when many SW "classics" were already released:
- Dark Forces
- Rebel Assault I and II
- X-Wing / TIE-FighterHad Lucas Arts ever released an SW Adventure game it would have pretty much owned the GotY Awards.
That news is irrelevent, it is the most critically accliamed Star Wars game ever. And it was the 2nd best xbox game on Game Spys poll, behind a little game called Halo 2. Let me post the rewards.International Game Developers Association Game of the Year
Original Game Character
Excellence in Writing
Check out the GDC Awards
Academy of Interactive Arts and Sciences Best Console RPG
Best PC RPG
Best Story
Best Character Development
Multiplayer.int Game of the Year
PC Game of the Year
Xbox Game of the Year
DICE summit PC Role Playing Game of the Year
Console Role-Playing Game of the Year
Outstanding Achievement in Character and Story Development
British Academy of Film and Television Arts Xbox Game of the Year
Check out the BAFTA Winners
Computer Gaming World 2003 Game of the Year
2003 RPG of the Year
Best Story
GameSpot
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
Reader’s Choice Runner up PC Game of the Year
Read the full review
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Best Xbox RPG
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Best PC RPG
Read the full review
Editor’s Choice Award
Best Game Based on a Film or TV Property
Read the full review
GameSpy
Game of the Year
Read the full review
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
Gamer's Choice - Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
PC RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Xbox RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Readers' Choice Award
for Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
Readers' Choice Award
for PC RPG of the Year
Read the full review
IGN
Game of the Year
Read the full review
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
PC Game of the Year
Read the full review
Editor’s Choice Award
Read the full review
Best Xbox RPG
Read the full review
Best PC RPG
Read the full review
Best Xbox Sound
Read the full review
Best PC Story
Best PC Music
PC Gamer Game of the Year
Spike TV - Video Game Award
Best Fantasy Game
Read the full review
Golden Joystick Award Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
Finalist, Overall Game of the Year
Read the full review
FHM "The Year's Best"
Amazon.com Best Xbox Game of 2003
Read the full review
Best Game of 2003
Read the full review
CNN.com Top Gaming Titles of 2003
Read the full review
1UP Awards Game of the Year
Read the full review
Best RPG
Read the full review
TechTV, X-Play Best Game of 2003
Read the full review
Best RPG
Read the full review
Electronic Gaming Monthly Game of the Year
Xbox Game of the Year
Readers' Choice RPG of the Year
Official Xbox Magazine Game of the Year
Best RPG
Readers’ Choice Game of the Year
Readers’ Choice RPG of the Year
Readers’ Choice Breakthrough Title
Cinescape Xbox Game of the Year
Pittsburgh Tribune Review Game of the Year
Maximum PC Single Player Game of the Year
GameZone
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
PC Game of the Year
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Game of the Year
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
Best PC RPG
Read the full review
Polygon Best of 2003
GameRevolution Game of the Year
Read the full review
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
San Francisco Chronicle Best of 2003
The International Press Academy Satellite Awards – New Media
Check out the award winners
Outstanding Execution of a Gaming Concept - Game of the Year
TeamXbox
Game of the Year
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Breakthrough Title
Read the full review
Readers’ Choice Best RPG
Read the full review
Editor’s Choice
Read the full review
RPGdot Best Xbox RPG
Best Graphics in an RPG
Read the full review
Best Sound in an RPG
Read the full review
RPG Vault Game of the Year
Read the full review
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Outstanding Achievement in Writing
Outstanding Achievement in Music
Outstanding Achievement in Sound
Outstanding Achievement in Voice Acting
Action Trip
Editor’s Choice Award
Read the full review
GamesDomain Top Game Award
Read the full review
Gamers Hell
Gold Hell Award
Read the full review
Dailygame.net Golden Thumb Award for Best Game of the Year
Read the full review
Best RPG of 2003
Read the full review
Best Time Suck
XGR.com Game of the Year
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Consolegold.com Game of the Year
Read the full review
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full review
RPGFan.com
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Shacknews Readers Choice Award for Xbox RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Readers Choice Award for PC RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Extremegamer.ca Game of the Year
Read the full review
RPG of the Year
Read the full review
Marin Independent Journal Game of the Year
Read the full review
Computer Games Magazine Game of the Year and RPG of the Year
Game Informer Game of the Year
RSC (European site) Game of the Year
Read the full review
Best Core RPG
Read the full review
Best Traditional RPG
Read the full review
Adrenaline Vault
Seal of Excellence
Read the full review
Loaded Inc
Hot Property Award
Read the full review
Worthplaying
Editor’s Choice
Read the full review
Netiak
Editor’s Choice
Read the full review
GD Xbox
Editor’s Choice
Read the full review
Gaming Nexus
Editor’s Choice
Read the full review
REVIEWS - Perfect Scores
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GMR 10 out of 10
Maximum PC 10 out of 10
Tech TV 10 out of 10
Computer Games Editor's Choice and 5/5
Computer Gaming World Editor's Choice and 5/5
PC Gamer 5 out of 5
Game Industry News 5 out of 5
GameSpy 5 out of 5
Avault 5 out of 5
Gaming Age A
UGO A
PGNX Network 10/10
Extreme Gamer 10/10
Thunderbolt 10/10
Xbox365 10/10
Game2extreme 10/10
Ace Games 10/10
Games Asylum 10/10
ZT Game Domain 10/10
MS Xbox World 10/10
Gamestyle 10/10
VG Force 10/10
PXDN Gamer 5/5
Xbox Addict 5/5
GDXbox 5/5
Globe Tech 5/5
Glide Underground 5/5
Games First 5/5
Gamer Dad 5/5
New Zealand Herald 5/5
Game Planet 5/5
Xbox Gamer Mag UK 5/5
Final Level 5/5
Stuff Gamer 5/5
Originally posted by Ushgarak
As if industry insider awards matter that much.X-Wing and TIE Fighter were far better games for their time than KOTOR.
But to answer your question? Because Battlefront is an on-line game, and they get buzz these days.
I agree with this 100%. THe old X-Wing and Tie FIghter game was awsome
Originally posted by Nactous
That news is irrelevent, it is the most critically accliamed Star Wars game ever. And it was the 2nd best xbox game on Game Spys poll, behind a little game called Halo 2. Let me post the rewards.International Game Developers Association Game of the YearOriginal Game Character
Excellence in Writing
Check out the GDC AwardsAcademy of Interactive Arts and Sciences Best Console RPG
Best PC RPG
Best Story
Best Character Development
Multiplayer.int Game of the Year
PC Game of the Year
Xbox Game of the Year
DICE summit PC Role Playing Game of the Year
Console Role-Playing Game of the Year
Outstanding Achievement in Character and Story Development
British Academy of Film and Television Arts Xbox Game of the Year
Check out the BAFTA WinnersComputer Gaming World 2003 Game of the Year
2003 RPG of the Year
Best Story
GameSpot
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewReader’s Choice Runner up PC Game of the Year
Read the full reviewRPG of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Best Xbox RPG
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Best PC RPG
Read the full reviewEditor’s Choice Award
Best Game Based on a Film or TV Property
Read the full reviewGameSpy
Game of the Year
Read the full reviewXbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewGamer's Choice - Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewPC RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewXbox RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders' Choice Award
for Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders' Choice Award
for PC RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewIGN
Game of the Year
Read the full reviewXbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewPC Game of the Year
Read the full reviewEditor’s Choice Award
Read the full reviewBest Xbox RPG
Read the full reviewBest PC RPG
Read the full reviewBest Xbox Sound
Read the full reviewBest PC Story
Best PC Music
PC Gamer Game of the Year
Spike TV - Video Game Award
Best Fantasy Game
Read the full reviewGolden Joystick Award Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewFinalist, Overall Game of the Year
Read the full reviewFHM "The Year's Best"
Amazon.com Best Xbox Game of 2003
Read the full reviewBest Game of 2003
Read the full reviewCNN.com Top Gaming Titles of 2003
Read the full review1UP Awards Game of the Year
Read the full reviewBest RPG
Read the full reviewTechTV, X-Play Best Game of 2003
Read the full reviewBest RPG
Read the full reviewElectronic Gaming Monthly Game of the Year
Xbox Game of the Year
Readers' Choice RPG of the Year
Official Xbox Magazine Game of the Year
Best RPG
Readers’ Choice Game of the Year
Readers’ Choice RPG of the Year
Readers’ Choice Breakthrough Title
Cinescape Xbox Game of the Year
Pittsburgh Tribune Review Game of the Year
Maximum PC Single Player Game of the Year
GameZone
Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewPC Game of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Game of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Xbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewBest PC RPG
Read the full reviewPolygon Best of 2003
GameRevolution Game of the Year
Read the full reviewRPG of the Year
Read the full reviewSan Francisco Chronicle Best of 2003
The International Press Academy Satellite Awards – New Media
Check out the award winnersOutstanding Execution of a Gaming Concept - Game of the Year
TeamXbox
Game of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Breakthrough Title
Read the full reviewReaders’ Choice Best RPG
Read the full reviewEditor’s Choice
Read the full reviewRPGdot Best Xbox RPG
Best Graphics in an RPG
Read the full reviewBest Sound in an RPG
Read the full reviewRPG Vault Game of the Year
Read the full reviewRPG of the Year
Read the full reviewOutstanding Achievement in Writing
Outstanding Achievement in Music
Outstanding Achievement in Sound
Outstanding Achievement in Voice Acting
Action Trip
Editor’s Choice Award
Read the full reviewGamesDomain Top Game Award
Read the full reviewGamers Hell
Gold Hell Award
Read the full reviewDailygame.net Golden Thumb Award for Best Game of the Year
Read the full reviewBest RPG of 2003
Read the full reviewBest Time Suck
XGR.com Game of the Year
RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewConsolegold.com Game of the Year
Read the full reviewRPG of the Year
Read the full reviewXbox Game of the Year
Read the full reviewRPGFan.com
RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewShacknews Readers Choice Award for Xbox RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewReaders Choice Award for PC RPG of the Year
Read the full reviewExtremegamer.ca Game of the Year
Read the full reviewRPG of the Year
Read the full reviewMarin Independent Journal Game of the Year
Read the full reviewComputer Games Magazine Game of the Year and RPG of the Year
Game Informer Game of the Year
RSC (European site) Game of the Year
Read the full reviewBest Core RPG
Read the full reviewBest Traditional RPG
Read the full reviewAdrenaline Vault
Seal of Excellence
Read the full reviewLoaded Inc
Hot Property Award
Read the full reviewWorthplaying
Editor’s Choice
Read the full reviewNetiak
Editor’s Choice
Read the full reviewGD Xbox
Editor’s Choice
Read the full reviewGaming Nexus
Editor’s Choice
Read the full reviewREVIEWS - Perfect Scores
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------GMR 10 out of 10
Maximum PC 10 out of 10
Tech TV 10 out of 10
Computer Games Editor's Choice and 5/5
Computer Gaming World Editor's Choice and 5/5
PC Gamer 5 out of 5
Game Industry News 5 out of 5
GameSpy 5 out of 5
Avault 5 out of 5
Gaming Age A
UGO A
PGNX Network 10/10
Extreme Gamer 10/10
Thunderbolt 10/10
Xbox365 10/10
Game2extreme 10/10
Ace Games 10/10
Games Asylum 10/10
ZT Game Domain 10/10
MS Xbox World 10/10
Gamestyle 10/10
VG Force 10/10
PXDN Gamer 5/5
Xbox Addict 5/5
GDXbox 5/5
Globe Tech 5/5
Glide Underground 5/5
Games First 5/5
Gamer Dad 5/5
New Zealand Herald 5/5
Game Planet 5/5
Xbox Gamer Mag UK 5/5
Final Level 5/5
Stuff Gamer 5/5
🙂