Professor Xavier vs. Doctor Strange
THE FIGHT TAKES PLACE ON THE ASTRAL PLANE.
PX: awful mighty telepath
supreme guardian of the astral plane
able to use the astral energies to cause almost any effect imaginable
DS: awful mighty magician
almost at home on the astral plane and other dimensions
able to use mystic energies to cause almost any effect imaginable
WHO WILL PREVAIL?
Strange is also a telepath, but so is of course Prof X. This will be a battle of the minds, and nothing is faster than the speed of thought, and since Xavier has LOTS or raw telepatic power and is used using them instantly, the edge goes to Xavier.
Prof. X should win. The longer the fight takes, the more probably Strange will win.
Originally posted by Smaxxer
Strange is also a telepath, but so is of course Prof X. This will be a battle of the minds, and nothing is faster than the speed of thought, and since Xavier has LOTS or raw telepatic power and is used using them instantly, the edge goes to Xavier.Prof. X should win. The longer the fight takes, the more probably Strange will win.
Actually, Strange is one of the only people who can take his physical weapons into the Astral plane. So, it's not just a battle of the mind.
Also, Strange's eye of agamotto basically makes him immune to mental assault.
Even if he doesn't use it, he's still an equal to Prof.X Ask Moondragon.
Originally posted by long pigThat fight with Moondragon was pretty cool, yes!
Actually, Strange is one of the only people who can take his physical weapons into the Astral plane. So, it's not just a battle of the mind.Also, Strange's eye of agamotto basically makes him immune to mental assault.
Even if he doesn't use it, he's still an equal to Prof.X Ask Moondragon.
Perhaps i should have made it more clear that i meant it to be a fight of pure personal power...so no Cerebra, Eye of Agamotto etc., just an astral battle of magic and mental discipline against telepathy.
Originally posted by PointinelLook at my sig...a man who is able to connect himself to the minds of the whole Skrull people and bypass the mental defenses of Galactus to preject their pain can't be THAT far behind the Doctor. Did i mention that Charles has beaten Dark Phoenix in a mental battle and that a telepath can do almost everything on the astral plane?!
*re-opens thread*strange > prof. x by miles
*closes thread again*
I think a fight with the given parameters would be pretty even and a wonderful scene to watch in comic! 😊
prof x = earth's most powerful telepath/mind
Earth's, yes. Universe? No.
Strange is Sorcerer Supreme over the universe, his mind powers are amped enough so that he can be effective in the universe.
Originally posted by wannabe
That fight with Moondragon was pretty cool, yes!Perhaps i should have made it more clear that i meant it to be a fight of pure personal power...so no Cerebra, Eye of Agamotto etc., just an astral battle of magic and mental discipline against telepathy.
Look at my sig...a man who is able to connect himself to the minds of the whole Skrull people and bypass the mental defenses of Galactus to preject their pain can't be THAT far behind the Doctor. Did i mentioned that Charles has beaten Dark Phoenix in a mental battle?!I think a fight with the given parameters would be pretty even and a wonderful scene to watch in comic! 😊
I still give it to Strange. He's much more experienced in Astral plane.
Also, he's STILL Prof X's equal in telepathy without the Eye, so allowing him to use magic, he curbstomps ol' charlie.
Originally posted by long pigSo can Charles in astral form (at least telepathically).
Earth's, yes. Universe? No.Strange is Sorcerer Supreme over the universe, his mind powers are amped enough so that he can be effective in the universe.
Originally posted by long pigIf you think that Strange will win...ok, possible! In a fight between man like them it can go either way imo. But to say that Strange is much more experienced on the astral plane is nonsense.
I still give it to Strange. He's much more experienced in Astral plane.
Also, he's STILL Prof X's equal in telepathy without the Eye, so allowing him to use magic, he curbstomps ol' charlie.
Strange may use magic to simulate telepathic effects, but he is no telepath by himself and certainly not Xavier's equal in this particular area without the Eye of Agamotto, which does not mean that he is not at all able to beat Charles without it.
Originally posted by willRulesPlease keep in mind that this fight takes place on the astral plane, where Xavier can do almost everything he can imagine, and that there are no helping tools allowed.
Xavier is better at telepathic abilities IMo but strange will win this cos he has some telepathic abilites and other powers........
If you think that Strange will win...ok, possible! In a fight between man like them it can go either way imo. But to say that Strange is much more experienced on the astral plane is nonsense.
Xavier is almost exclusively working astrally, is AT LEAST as old as Strange, practiced telepathy earlier in his lifetime than Strange learned to use magic in his, and he was stated by Shadowking, a being who LIVES on the astral plane, to be the planes most powerful guardian.
Strange is thousands of years old. He spent near 5000 years fighting gods. Check out his respect thread.
Strange may use magic to simulate telepathic effects, but he is no telepath by himself and certainly not Xavier's equal in this particular area without the Eye of Agamotto, which does not mean that he is not at all able to beat Charles without it.
Strange has shown telepathic abilities in almost every single issue he's ever been in. He is the Sorcerer Supreme of this universe, why wouldn't a gaurdian of a whole universe be the best telepath?
Strange is, at LEAST Charles' equal if not total superior in telepathy.
You're taking the slogan "Worlds greatest telepath" too serious.