Originally posted by Metalmanx
No way. Batman would have to fight Batgirl. Daredevil would fight Elektra (and win eventually), and Cap would have to just hold his own (basically stall) against Lady Shiva until the others can come to his aid and defeat her through their combined efforts.
Why would Batman have to fight Batgirl? Daredevil would match up much better against her imo.
Id have Batman fight Shiva, and Cap fight Electra.
The men's team would win due to advantages outside of combat skill. The men's team has better leadership in Captain America, weapons with batman and battlefield sense with DD. With DD on the team, the women will have a difficult time surprising the men. Batman also seems to have a lot more gadgets than batgirl.
If they were fighting indoors what's to stop Capt from shutting off the lights to allow DD and batman (with his built in lens nightvision) from gaining a huge combat advantage over the women (I don't think batgirl has nightvision lens in that weird mask of hers). Batman vs Shiva in pure darkness I'd give it to Batman. DD vs elektra in darkness I'd give it to DD as well. Capt can stalemate batgirl until DD and Batman arrive.
If they were fighting in an outdoor environment Batman throws a bunch of smoke grenades/flashbangs at Shiva's general direction. DD versus Shiva in thick smoke and blinding light = a DD win imo. Batman beats Electra And Capt will hold his own vs batgirl until DD and batman come to help finish her off