dark phoenix vs silver surfer

DP>rachel>=<galactus>>>>>>>silver surfer>>>>>>>>Xorneto>Phoenix

and thus, the suicide theory. which while impossible to prove is equally impossible to disprove.

I have,

The only reason Rachel did that to galactus is cause she got the drop on him while he was feeding. Element of suprise, nothing more.

Phoenix has been killed by many methods far weaker then that of the SS.

All he has to do by forum rules is kill her once which he can do with a high powered blast. She's been killed by less. Resurection doesnt matter under forum rules.

If you Phoenix Fanboys can't accept that shes not all-powerful you need to find another board cause as you've seen on this one we don't accept it.

And if you dont like the rules of the forum then go elsewhere, Phoenix Fanboy.

Wow. GS really did a number on Phoenix's credibility. I hate the Phoenix, but even I realize that the Dark Phoenix would crush the Silver Surfer.

i completely agree with celestial demon. yes, including the hating phoenix part.

phoenix may have been killed by less, but she's also taken more. and the rachel v galactus fight lasted more than a surprise shot panel. it's not like galactus was unawares for the remainder of the fight after the initial blow. in fact, there was a conversation inbetween.

She's been killed by people and methods far weaker then the Surfer.

He was in the middle of feeding, if galactus had the time to use all the weapons on his ship, phoenix would go down in flames as she always has.

i don't really condone recycling. so stop "spamming". is there a term for reverse fanboy?

you still haven't proved that any of the methods aside from an AU (non-canon) wolverine killing (which really shows more about wolverine's multiversal jobber aura) are weaker than surfer. and you still haven't countered the suicide theory, nor the fact she's also taken damage far greater than surfer.

in fact, you've done nothing but repeat yourself, ignore counterpoints, call everyone who disagrees with you a phoenix fanboy, and be a general t wat about the whole thing. at least other detractors are coherent.

if galactus had preptime, you mean?

What is DP going to do to beat Surfer?

something along the lines of telekinetically dispersing him.

Originally posted by celestialdemon
Wow. GS really did a number on Phoenix's credibility. I hate the Phoenix, but even I realize that the Dark Phoenix would crush the Silver Surfer.

Originally posted by thedude1948
What is DP going to do to beat Surfer?

Originally posted by manorastroman
something along the lines of telekinetically dispersing him.

And she can do this to someone on Surfer's power level and Molecular Manipulating ability?

And people like who has been able to do this to Surfer?

luckily, extants friends who actually know what they're talking about have come to his rescue. unfortunately, thedude is just using rhetorical misdirection.

pick a method. DP has so much more raw power than surfer it's ridiculous.

Originally posted by bigbran
Yup. Look, I'm one of the more knowledgable one's on Surfer. He isn't beating DP. In fact, Surfer is my second favorite character along with Galactus, Tyrant. So ya...

I really dont think Surfer is anywhere near DP level either, I just want to hear a legitimate way he is going to get killed from people saying he gets annihilated (Which he probably would be, but how?).

Originally posted by manorastroman

pick a method. DP has so much more raw power than surfer it's ridiculous.

I do think Dark Phoenix wins 10/10. But she isnt going to snap her fingers and disperse his body around the universe.

Actually since Exiles is held as a canon book, that kill counts.

And Phoenix had unfair prep to wound Galactus cause she jumped him.

And you have done nothing but repeat yourself. In exiles she had lost all her humanity and wasn't holding back any more. No suicide there.

All he has to do to beat DP is kill the Avatar which he can do easily.

And don't criticize me for being incoherent, when you can't even spell corretly or use proper grammar?

Wasn't David Richards a Phoenix Fanboy? I think we have a return visitor here.

You Fanboy's need to realize shes not the almighty being you think she is.

SS can kill her at least once which is all he has to do to win the match under the rules. If you don't like the rules go elsewhere.

Originally posted by Ext@nt

SS can kill her at least once which is all he has to do to win the match under the rules. If you don't like the rules go elsewhere.

She's on a higher level than Surfer, is all together.

when did i spell something "incorretly"(hypocrite)? dang, looks like i'll have to move on to the looking glass. now hush.

you are the only person who thinks silver surfer would win. you are much more an anti-fanboy than anybody is a fanboy. and you STILL didn't counter anything, just mentioned wolverine's multiversal jobber aura.

Originally posted by Ext@nt
Actually since Exiles is held as a canon book, that kill counts.

And Phoenix had unfair prep to wound Galactus cause she jumped him.

And you have done nothing but repeat yourself. In exiles she had lost all her humanity and wasn't holding back any more. No suicide there.

All he has to do to beat DP is kill the Avatar which he can do easily.

And don't criticize me for being incoherent, when you can't even spell corretly or use proper grammar?

Wasn't David Richards a Phoenix Fanboy? I think we have a return visitor here.

You Fanboy's need to realize shes not the almighty being you think she is.

SS can kill her at least once which is all he has to do to win the match under the rules. If you don't like the rules go elsewhere.

that a lot of bull dude just because you don't agree with somebody doesn't make them a fanboy that just like in the 50's when everyone was a comunist if they didn't agree with macarthy. The fact of the matter is, that when phoneix was at her weekest she was stated to be as powerfull as thor. at her strongest (x-men forever or what ever the crap that book was called) even the living tribunal bowed to her. So while I can see the argument for Gal vs. Phoneix this is nearly a spite thread. (by the way the whole xorn crap was PIS Jean just lived though almost kissing the sun then a plantary strok kills her that's just bad writting) ........ you fanboy

If Wolverine can kill her with claws, If a Laser turret can vaporize her, if shi-ar and other alien vessels can wound her then SS can kill the stupid avatar as many times as need be.