luminara vs. ROTS obi-wan

i apologize if its been done i searched but didnt see it
both are masters of soresu
they are very powerful
so who wins

💃

i wanted the banana

Oh my god! Obi wan pwns

I swear this has been done before. Anyway, I really don't know, Luminara I feel more edged to say.

Luminara is very power in The Approaching Storm, but I have to say Obi

my top 5 jedi in ROTS
yoda
mace
obi (Anakin would be here if he wasn't retarted)
anakin(he still is awsome)
Quinlan Vos (he is very powerful and i think more so then luminara)

anyone disagree?

I dunno about quinlan...

Woops in my first post i wrote "power" not "powerful"

Originally posted by Darth Avis
my top 5 jedi in ROTS
yoda
mace
obi (Anakin would be here if he wasn't retarted)
anakin(he still is awsome)
Quinlan Vos (he is very powerful and i think more so then luminara)

anyone disagree?

I do.

(Bodo Baas might be in the top ten.)
Yoda
Mace
Obi-wan
Anakin
Cin
Depa
Quin
Luminara

oh yea tottaly forgot cin

Luminara might be in the top 5 strongest jedi (in ROTS). She's for sure in the top 10. But she couldn't beat Kenobi.

Mace specifically states Obi-wan is better in the ROTS novel.

no winner they wont attack each other soresu is a way to defend only and they both are proud to be invincible not ferocious but in the novel obi-wan is held as the only master by mace windu

This is extremely close. I'd say that Luminara has a slight edge on Obi-Wan with saber skills, but Obi-Wan is stronger in the force. I'd say Obi-Wan, just.

why did you bring this back?

I thought that this would be an interesting fight, and instead of creating a brand new thread, I thought I would just bring back an old one.