Just checking

Is there anyone on the planet who thinks episodes I or II are superior to III?

I don't know, I haven't talked to every being on Earth.

Probably not. Maybe if you're under the age of 6...

Gah, a friend of mine on my course thinks AOTC is better than the other two.

And you know what? She thinks Temple of Doom is the best Indiana Jones film.

How do these things HAPPEN?

Ushgarak, you have a strange friend there. I would like to hear the reasons why AOTC is the best of the PT

Episode 3 isnt THAT GOOD, Its only abit better than episode 2

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Gah, a friend of mine on my course thinks AOTC is better than the other two.

And you know what? She thinks Temple of Doom is the best Indiana Jones film.

How do these things HAPPEN?

AOTC is a lot better than TPM. But it falls short of ROTS, IMO.

I can see how someone would like Temple of Doom more than the other two. Personally, I like them all equally, maybe Raiders of the Lost Ark a little more than the other two.

But let's face it, The Phantom Menace is garbage.

AOTC is the only one with a forced romance plot.

This noob who calls himself supershadow thinks the phantom menace is the best movie of all times, because of the money it made and a character named Jar Jar Gabore.

Originally posted by overlord
This noob who calls himself supershadow thinks the phantom menace is the best movie of all times, because of the money it made and a character named Jar Jar Gabore.

Well it wasn't a joke this time. That's why it's low quality, it's the aweful truth..

I think that the darth maul obi wan Qui Gonn fight/ padme firefight getting her throne back/ gungan war/ naboo pilots attacking the control ship scenes is one of the best cut action scenes in all of star wars. I think PM is one of my least favorite episodes, but for those 10 minutes, its about the best.

Yeah I always enjoyed the scenes from the beginning of the Maul duel, to the end of it.