dark phoenix vs galactus

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Irrelevant when theyre current continuity and those that dispute them havent been able to come up with a solid argument as to why the ideas arent true. If you can speak up otherwise shhhh. 🙂

Not quite true either, no real answer to who Phoenix has ever beaten above herald or if the Phoenix force weilder can even be considered anything but a tool.
The Phoenix weilder can obviously be destroyed its happed. Jean and the Phoenix despite your ideas are not always one as people like I have stated as Jean is in shards.

your comment is irrelevant you have proven little beyond function - a light switch can light a room, its little use in a fist fight 🙂

Well I still think she could beat galactus, I think she is maybe the most powerful supervillain in the marvel universe. No one was able to stop her she died cause she commited suicide, but when it has come to galactus he has been beaten.

Originally posted by Gandhi_of_KMC
Not quite true either, no real answer to who Phoenix has ever beaten above herald or if the Phoenix force weilder can even be considered anything but a tool.
The Phoenix weilder can obviously be destroyed its happed. Jean and the Phoenix despite your ideas are not always one as people like I have stated as Jean is in shards.

your comment is irrelevant you have proven little beyond function - a light switch can light a room, its little use in a fist fight 🙂

If you actually visited the link as quoting it would suggest you'll see that it was pertaining to the relationship between Jean and Phoenix and the various retcons. Therefore all the above is unnecessary garbage. Its not even connected with the link so why quote it?

Phoenix is the power of creation, the hosts are the tools used to carry out its work within reality.

As for Phoenix defeating anyone above herald level, in all of her encounters with Galactus she has had the upper hand and in the most recent one he highlighted the finite nature of his power in comparison to the unlimited nature of hers so again your point is moot.

Since those encounters the phoenix interpretation has changed and we now know that Phoenix is the power source of creation and that Galactus' very power stems from her (F4 522, Off F4 HBk 2005) on top of that comics like New Xmen showed us how truly futile it is to try and make a point out of lack of battle feats when the being in question can hold the universe in the palm of her hand and restructure it on a whim.

Your point that Jean and Phoenix are not always one because she is in shards makes no sense and stems from naivete. The fact that the shard was acknowledged by itself and by Jean on panel as a part of Jean says all that needs to be said. Read the comic mate dont spout off inaccuracies after reading hearsay.

Another essayists equally valid ideas

http://hem.passagen.se/hggblom1/phoenix/phoenix.htm

lots of other people on different forums and different places disagree 🙂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Ghandi 🤘

the first paragraph says it all 😉

"The story about The Phoenix force is very complicated, and different writers and artists have had different views about what it is... here I will try to explain what the Phoenix is... (my special thanks go to David Morgan who sent me the back issues of Excalibur)"

So....... opinions are divided

Originally posted by Gandhi_of_KMC
Another essayists equally valid ideas

http://hem.passagen.se/hggblom1/phoenix/phoenix.htm

You've just googled phoenix and posted a link to a phoenix bio. Thats irrelevant because this link isnt taking me to an argument which shows how the events of the likes of New X-men and Endsong can still be interpreted as per the 86 retcon.

As such thats just an outdated bio that makes no mention of recent comic events.

Sorry mate but youve wasted your time. 🙂

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
You've just googled phoenix and posted a link to a phoenix bio. Thats irrelevant because this link isnt taking me to an argument which shows how the events of the likes of New X-men and Endsong can still be interpreted as per the 86 retcon.

As such thats just an outdated bio that makes no mention of recent comic events.

Sorry mate but youve wasted your time. 🙂

its not a bio at all 🙂

read it - learn something about Phoenix 🙂

don't get all stressy - you always do 🙂

LOL 😂 😂 😆 😆

Originally posted by Gandhi_of_KMC
Another essayists equally valid ideas

http://hem.passagen.se/hggblom1/phoenix/phoenix.htm

lots of other people on different forums and different places disagree 🙂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Ghandi 🤘

the first paragraph says it all 😉

"The story about The Phoenix force is very complicated, and different writers and artists have had different views about what it is... here I will try to explain what the Phoenix is... (my special thanks go to David Morgan who sent me the back issues of Excalibur)"

So....... opinions are divided

If you actually read it properly you'd see that the events it details leads up to when Cyclops and Jean visited Mother Askani back in 1994. This isnt someone who has looked at recent events and interpreted them as per the 86 retcon still. Thats just a bio 11 years out of date LOL 😂

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
If you actually read it properly you'd see that the events it details leads up to when Cyclops and Jean visited Mother Askani back in 1994. This isnt someone who has looked at recent events and interpreted them as per the 86 retcon still. Thats just a bio 11 years out of date LOL 😂

but the bit pertaining to the galactus confrontation with Phoenix is not and the thread is about Dark Phoenix 🙂 sorry you lost again 🙂

Do you guy's always fight?

Originally posted by Gandhi_of_KMC
but the bit pertaining to the galactus confrontation with Phoenix is not and the thread is about Dark Phoenix 🙂 sorry you lost again 🙂

Ummm it said Phoenix attempted to stop Galactus from eating the planet which is true and then he talked her out of doing so. Hardly helping your case mate. 😂

Dark phoenix would win cause she is just so powerful.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Ummm it said Phoenix attempted to stop Galactus from eating th eplanet which is true an dthen he talked her out of doing so. Hardly helping your case mate. 😂

He also told her he could beat her which she accepted 🙂 Remember the Phoenix and Jean are one 🙂 So the Phoenix knew the truth of his statement 🙂

Originally posted by Gandhi_of_KMC
Dark Phoenix never beat Galactus - he accepted her as an equal but told her he could beat even her 🙂

and no need to bullshit

there is a reason why they made Darkpho battle a weak nearly dying Galactus

nuff said.

Originally posted by kgkg
exactly thx u

and no need to bullshit

there is a reason why they made Darkpho battle a weak nearly dying Galactus

nuff said.

no thankyou KgKg commonsense still exists 🙂

Originally posted by Gandhi_of_KMC
He also told her he could beat her which she accepted 🙂 Remember the Phoenix and Jean are one 🙂 So the Phoenix knew the truth of his statement 🙂

Youre getting things all muddled my dear. The website is referring to the Excalibur fight where Galactus admitted his finite reserves in comparison to Phoenixes unlimited power.

Youre talking about the What If Phoenix had not died battle where a limited Phoenix says that due to the lobotomy if theres anyone who reaches her limitations its Galactus. She fought him and found that she still had enough juice to chase him off. She went on to recover from the lobotomy and then she destroyed the universe and Galactus along with. 😂 Moot point. 😂

On top of that the threadmaker says we're talking about current continuity Phoenix if she reverted to dark phoenix. As we know how much more powerful she is theres no need to argue here Phoenix wins. Even KG admits current continuity Phoenix wins so youre very much on youre own im afraid. 🙁

HEELLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!! I know this is a wierd q but are you a woman or a man galactic storm?

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Youre getting things all muddled my dear. The website is referring to the Excalibur fight where Galactus admitted his finite reserves in comparison to Phoenixes unlimited power.

Youre talking about the What If Phoenix had not died battle where a limited Phoenix says that due to the lobotomy if theres anyone who reaches her limitations its Galactus. She fought him and found that she still had enough juice to chase him off. She went on to recover from the lobotomy and then she destroyed the universe and Galactus along with. 😂 Moot point. 😂

On top of that the threadmaker says we're talking about current continuity Phoenix if she reverted to dark phoenix. As we know how much more powerful she is theres no need to argue here Phoenix wins. Even KG admits current continuity Phoenix wins so youre very much on youre own im afraid. 🙁

Then no dark phoenix exists in current continuity - the what if battle is part of the multiverse isn't the phoenix force "multiversal" , So the Galactus of that reality is stronger than Phoenix 🙂 is that what your saying 😖hifty:

Originally posted by kgkg
exactly thx u

and no need to bullshit

there is a reason why they made Darkpho battle a weak nearly dying Galactus

nuff said.

Your point is moot when it was a weak phoenix versus a weak galactus. Theres no excuses here my friend 😂

She said cos of her lobotomy caused limits that she thought Galactus at that point would be able to reach or surpass her power level at the time. She found she had enough juice and chased him off.

She then regained her power and destroyed the universe and Galactus so youre arguing over nothing lol

Originally posted by steverules
HEELLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!! I know this is a wierd q but are you a woman or a man galactic storm?