Has your opinion of ROTS changed since you first saw it?

Started by exanda kane4 pages
Originally posted by queeq
THere were more. I loved Ewan's OB1.... outstanding. And Ian was great (although I hate his rubber mask)

He seemed to tense for me, too nervous. But then I suppose It was a shock for me in comparison to ultra calm Ben in ANH.

I didn't like some of the dialog. I didn't like Sidous some of the time. I liked his transformation at first. Is it just me or did the structure of his face keep changing. At first he had a but crack on his head, then later on he seemed a little normal like the way he was before the lightning, then during the Yoda/Sidious fight he looked fat when they did the close ups on his face when the chanceller thingy was rising up. He also cackled way to much, and when he wasn't cackling he was whining like a *****.

i was slightly dissapointed

I think i liked it better in theaters

It just didnt have that same effect as it did in the movie theater

Originally posted by exanda kane
He seemed to tense for me, too nervous. But then I suppose It was a shock for me in comparison to ultra calm Ben in ANH.

He better be tense. There's a war going on, he has to fight and Grievous. And he feels the Jedi ,losing control and Anakin slipping to the Dark Side. PLenty of reason to be tense.

And as for Ben... after 20 years in the desert, there's plenty of practise to be ultra calm.

I'm OK with the "Nooooooooo" scene now but Grievous loses cool points because of his stupid pantomine villain voice. His voice just makes him seem unintelligent. He could have been a much more evil and "bad" villain if he didn't talk at all or had a similar voice to EPII Boba Fett.

Or the ESB Boba Fett voice, which was a lot better than Morrison.

"A lot" doesn't begin to describe how much better the old ESB Boba Fett voice was...

Originally posted by queeq
Or the ESB Boba Fett voice, which was a lot better than Morrison.
Oops, that's what I meant!

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
"A lot" doesn't begin to describe how much better the old ESB Boba Fett voice was...

I was being gentle. I really really miss it when I see the DVD.