Mace Windu v Samurai Jack

yes it was

Jack could do all of that, very easily.

Originally posted by 00.y
Jack could do all of that, very easily.

I agree Jack is ridiculous 🙂

lol I watch the show dude no jacks would of died. jacks is so out match it is not funny

Maybe these two have comics, but the TV show is the primary source for Jack, and Star Wars is seen trhough other mediums as well. I'm moving this.

Please go to the link in my sig or just check the rules thread...the new rules deal directly with stuff like this.

Originally posted by wolverine8888
lol I watch the show dude no jacks would of died. jacks is so out match it is not funny

It's quite the opposite. Mace wouldn't even know what hit him.

I saw an episode where Samurai Jack were hunted by 4 beasts I think, where 1 of them could beat or at least match him. They we're equipped with normal bows and strong swords and made Jack flee. I know he is an excellent fighter, I'm still thinking about whos going to win. But saying he can't or has never lost a fight is a bit of overreacting, you have to explain why he flee in that situation before I'll make a decision.

Weren't those lion dudes revered as the best hunters in the galaxy?

Yeah I think they we're, still he couldent take them which means he aint undefeatable. Though I guess that was pretty much in the beginning of the whole thing, has he gotten any better since then, if he has would he be able to take them now?

Remember the conditions here peeps Mace can't use the force.. With the force he would win.. Without hes lost most of what made him uber...

Originally posted by JediMasterLuke5
Mace still easily takes him. Mace is the best duelist of all time.

Jack was the best swordsman in his own time, AND he is the best when in the future.

Well he said force powers which is the likes of force push, pull etc but not stripped totally of the force. So he will still be able to predict movement and do incredible moves or whatever he can do.

Originally posted by 00.y
Weren't those lion dudes revered as the best hunters in the galaxy?

Yes. And Jango Fett was revered as the best bounty hunter in the Galaxy and the "deadliest man in the Galaxy" and still Mace wasted him.

And for the clone wars battle on Dantooine:
- Mace destroyed hundrets of Super Battle droids with his force powers
- he punched through durasteel with his bare hands (!)
- he dodged blaster bolts being fired at him
- he reflected blaster bolts back fired at him from different directions
- he moved damn fast (force speed)
- he jumped hundrets of yards in the air on the Hoovertank
- he jumped about a mile from the battlefield to a hill

If force powers are allowed Mace would destroy Jack.

Originally posted by Borbarad
Yes. And Jango Fett was revered as the best bounty hunter in the Galaxy and the "deadliest man in the Galaxy" and still Mace wasted him.

And for the clone wars battle on Dantooine:
- Mace destroyed hundrets of Super Battle droids with his force powers
- he punched through durasteel with his bare hands (!)
- he dodged blaster bolts being fired at him
- he reflected blaster bolts back fired at him from different directions
- he moved damn fast (force speed)
- he jumped hundrets of yards in the air on the Hoovertank
- he jumped about a mile from the battlefield to a hill

If force powers are allowed Mace would destroy Jack.

Considering that Clone Wars and Samurai Jack are from the SAME creators, I am not suprised of that.

Yup most jedis would own jack.. for the force is very powerful..

Mace couldn't do one of those feats without the force Borbarad
.. Jack could do a few..

But without the force mace is toast... and seeing as whirly the threader specified no force.. Who wins??

You notice how you are only referring to The Clone Wars series? That is because you want Mace to win and TCW exaggerated characters...a lot. Yoda lifted up a ship and crashed it into another one, it's ridiculous. Mace took out the screws in battle droids, used them as bullets, punched through many droids and jumped like a mile. Mace is not actually that powerful, no Jedi even the ancient Sith Lords are that martial.

If Windu couldn't catch Jack in force crush, there's no way he could beat him.

Originally posted by jollyjim311
You notice how you are only referring to The Clone Wars series? That is because you want Mace to win and TCW exaggerated characters...a lot. Yoda lifted up a ship and crashed it into another one, it's ridiculous. Mace took out the screws in battle droids, used them as bullets, punched through many droids and jumped like a mile. Mace is not actually that powerful, no Jedi even the ancient Sith Lords are that martial.

If Windu couldn't catch Jack in force crush, there's no way he could beat him.

What makes you think the Ancient Sith Lords aren't that Martial? Comic books have illustrated feats of Nadd or Kun or have described them in detail that would quite easily put them up there.

Maybe because we're refering TCW because Mace was only in 2 Action scenes in the entire frigging saga? And if you're blind, I should remind you that BobNai did reference him beating Jango Fett, who was considered the most dangeorus man in the Galaxy which includes millions of planets and trillions upon trillions of individuals. There's simply a FAR deeper field of talent to choose from.

Watch TCW, read Shatterpoint, watch Mace put Sidious on his ass.

And besides, if you say the TCW exaggerates for Mace, they exaggerate for Jack too. The fact of the matter is they are made by the same creator. And the fact of the matter is that Mace DID punch through durasteel at rapid speed and fight off hundreds of battledroids at once, even without a lightsaber.

Ok, all fair and well, but just answer me this Illustrious: Do you think that TCW exaggerates how good people really are?

Sure, it may well exaggerate the motions and the visuals, but it doesn't exaggerate the feats, which are official. And besides, if TCW exaggerates, so does Samurai Jack as they are by the same creators.

If you want to have a feat by feat comparison, Mace wins.

Well was Samuri Jack a comic? If it was then I am not a valid source for argument because I don't know enough about it. However if the television show is the origional, then it can't be exaggerated, it's the first. TCW is a series that exaggerates the origional, so you are comparing something that is the normal for the character (Jack), to something that is overpowered (Windu) and they are still close in powers, so Jack should be molre powerful.

Sound reasonable?