sad moment in x-men history

am i the only one who thought cassandra nova launching the extermination of genosha was more "sad" than this quesada-inspired "no more mutants" line?

Ooo..that reminds me..the comic where Lorna boosts the signal of the black box on Genosha and all last moments of all the people are revealled..and then Magneto speaks..it's quite powerful....I posted pages from it awhile ago..

Originally posted by Fianna
Ooo..that reminds me..the comic where Lorna boosts the signal of the black box on Genosha and all last moments of all the people are revealled..and then Magneto speaks..it's quite powerful....I posted pages from it awhile ago..

I agree that was a really sad scene.

Originally posted by Disappear
am i the only one who thought cassandra nova launching the extermination of genosha was more "sad" than this quesada-inspired "no more mutants" line?

Who found the no more mutants scene sad? Didnt do anything for me to be honest. I agree the Cassandra Nova thing was far more touching imo

Grant Morrison & Chuck Austen. ' Nuff Said.

Originally posted by nathan summers
Grant Morrison & Chuck Austen. ' Nuff Said.

and Frank Quietly worst artist in this or any reality!!! Chuck wasn't so bad though.

Originally posted by Mainstream
and Frank Quietly worst artist in this or any reality!!! Chuck wasn't so bad though.

I quite like Quitelys work. I loved it in New X-men.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
I quite like Quitelys work. I loved it in New X-men.

I do like the way he drew lips but other than that I could stand him.

sad events ppl

Quietly, Liefeld, Austen and Morrison are sad events. ✅

Originally posted by Disappear
am i the only one who thought cassandra nova launching the extermination of genosha was more "sad" than this quesada-inspired "no more mutants" line?

I really didn't find the extermination of Genosha sad... we knew none of them... and anyone we did know of there survived.... but HOM was more dramatic because lots of people's favourites have currently lost their powers.... but as we know thye will get them back

Originally posted by botcherby
sadest moment for me, have been when both Cyclops and Iceman returned as kick ass mutants, only to be reduced to trash in a matter of months as new creative teams replace the then current. With Cyclops when he returned from Apoc's control and kicked butt in Genosha, but then became an insecure *** in Quitely's run. With Iceman, short after zero tolerance, having single handely taken down Bastion and then reduced to an insecure *** in Austen's run.

* true!

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
I really don't think it's all that sad... at least for the reader of the comic when Jean dies for like the eleventh time..

Doug Ramsey's death was sad for the New Mutants.

Colossus has a lot of sad moments. Illyana's death. His parents being murdered. Mikhail's death. His own death.

Kitty Pryde lost Colossus, lost her father on Genosha (if I remember right).

Forge was a bastard to Storm, when he reneged on his marriage proposal.

we all are sweetie lol

But then she is Phoenix..and the whole thing about Phoenix's is that they die and come back to life..so it's got to be expected...still annoying but understandable..

yea the phoenix thing is a little annoying

i got a name change!!!!(again)

the saddest thing that ever happend in xmen history,was when hollywood got their grubby little hands on them and made a movie out of them.like most comicbook movies,they decided to betray the spirit of the comics by changing their costumes. 😠

Originally posted by Crystal_Frost
yea the phoenix thing is a little annoying