Malak, Bastila and Ventress versus Anakin, Obi-Wan and Quinlan Vos

ROTS versions, who wins?

Ack, poll is wrong. It should read Vos and company.

This is kinda cruel. Malak alone is a Sith Lord of decent power and certainly no slouch in lightsaber combat. He could engage Anakin and Obi-Wan simultaneously and disable one of them quickly. Ventress on her own is deadly. With Bastila as backup they could overtake Vos. Mop up time.

Yeah, Bastilla could afford to use her meditation because Malak could hold off 2 and Ventress hold off another. Both teams are good, but Malak's is better.

Hm. Good match-up. Although I think the Dark Side team takes this. Malak can defeat any one of these guys pretty easily, and he should be able to coordinate pretty well with Bastila. Nothing compared to Anakin and Obi-Wan in terms of partnership and cooperation, but they won't be all too terrible.

Ventress is going to go off on her own. She could likely take out Quinlan, the good guys' weakest, on her own, but it would require more effort than the norm.

On her own, Bastila is the evil dudes' weak link. She's most likely a very good duelist, coming close to or on par with Ventress. But she's as brash as Anakin, contrasting greatly with Asaaj's cool and cunning mindset. I think Anakin or Obi-Wan could defeat her.

Malak, however, is by far the best duelist and most powerful person here. Neither Anakin nor Obi-Wan will last long against him. So he tips the battle into the evil trio's favor.

However, replace Vos with Windu, and have you a hard fight.

Originally posted by Ianus
This is kinda cruel. Malak alone is a Sith Lord of decent power and certainly no slouch in lightsaber combat. He could engage Anakin and Obi-Wan simultaneously and disable one of them quickly. Ventress on her own is deadly. With Bastila as backup they could overtake Vos. Mop up time.

Agreed, Malak's team takes this

No competition.

Ack, what the hell. I'm pulling an Avis and changing Vos for Windu.

Then I gotta change my vote, Windu would be very strong in lighsaber battle against Malak. Anakin could take Ventress and Obi should kill Bastila after a nice battle..

Malak and his girlfriends wins. Ventress takes Obi-Wan. Bastila fights Anakin, Malak beats Quinlan and helps whoever is still fighting.

Why is Bastila considered to be weak? She was pretty powerful in her right.

I agree, Bastila is often underrated. Malak takes Mace, Bastila defeats Anakin, Ventress holds off Obi-wan until Malak can come help her.

Even without her Battle Meditation she was quite the warrior. The Jedi Council considered her at least to be a threat to Revan, otherwise they wouldn't have sent her to take Revan on.

I also remember somewhere in the game that Malak called her more powerful than Bandon. That would definatly make her very powerful, considering she became even more powerful after the point that he said that.

I'd have to disagree. Obi-Wan could take Asajj, Anakin could hold off Bastilla, but not beat her, Mace could hold off Malak. Then Obi-Wan could help him out. Then they could all gang up on Bastilla. Well, this fight actually depends on who's fighting who. If it were like Obi-Wan v.s.
Malak, it'd be quite different.