Reed Richards v The Phoenix of the White Crown

Originally posted by hoorayforpeepee
you're a little late gettin on this boat, whirly

not dismissed 🙂

Originally posted by Creshosk
No, that's what you're doing. 😖

You descrie phoenix to be a certain way. when that certian way is not seen, you say that there must not be a phoenix.

But its simply the way you define Phoenix that's wrong.

✅ Well put

Originally posted by kgkg
Reed because it's a NEW RETCON

😈

not dismissed

Originally posted by Evil Genius
and I told you I have been here a month GS has not been away that long Whirly laughed at him in here a couple of weeks ago I remeber seeing it.

Who exactly has yet to be determined. You pre-knowledge claims speak volumes for you.

Possibly Whirly with how you keep mirroring him.

"Rubbish" "You never prove anything" etc. etc.

Originally posted by thesilverspider
reed >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> pheonix

not dismissed

Originally posted by Sir Whirlysplat
not dimissed 🙂

Originally posted by roughrider
Well, I did think GS put too many eggs in one basket over Phoenix.
Poor sod. If it's true, he may never return, or have to start a new identity.blowup

not dismissed

🙂 I like that one

Originally posted by roughrider
Kabballah = Bulls**t?

agreed 🙂

Originally posted by Sir Whirlysplat
not dismissed

🙂 I like that one

Originally posted by Ultimate Rage
indeed they dont......+ as someone said kabbalah is B.S

agreed

Originally posted by Sir Whirlysplat
agreed 🙂

Fillibuster. 😛

Originally posted by Maestro
HaHa I see GS checking into a psycoatric ward, after wasting all that time trying to made a valid argument for Phoenix.

😆

😆

i have a massive erection

Originally posted by Blair Wind
cool....awesomeness...

yup 🙂

and the filibuster continues.

Originally posted by Juntai
Go back a page or two, the entire set of scans is there.

indeed it is 🙂 thanks Juntai

Originally posted by roughrider
I gently advised him about getting too wrapped up in Phoenix; Marvel has changed their minds in the past about her and would again, but he didn't hear me.

so true

Originally posted by long pig
GS does make some good points, whirly. You must agree.

I would like to see the rest of this story played out before I jump to any conclusions.

But, like I said: Being a fan of one of the top 3 most powerful entities in marvel isn't very smart unless you're prepared for recons. They DO change it every 10 or so years.

Like i said in the other forum thats cool i have no problem with a retcon because i can still debate with all powerful White Crown Phoenix in mind.

However there has been no retcon from whats been shown in the latest F4.

Nowhere does it state Phoenix isnt the big bang. We've just been given a schedule for the Big Bang every creation cycle. Thats all.

My scans show and state that Eternitys questions are what caused the Big Bang. Reed and the Entity went back pre 616 and asked the same questions resulting in the Big Bang again. It was later stated that all life and creation are as much a part of the universe as the stars and that life was initiated because of ETERNITYS questions on existence.

No ReedForce no all powerful cosmic bunny.

By Whirlys logic Galactus no longer exists in Marvel because he wasnt shown. 🙄

and so on ad infinitum, but I'm bored 🙂

Originally posted by Creshosk
GS has been absent during the time you've been here.

No, they show precisely what they show.

None of the other scans really show anything either.

I never said that. I'm asking you haw can you know that by your words "GS never proves anything" if the only time that you've been here is when GS has been away?

The only way you could claim such knowledge is if yopu've been here while GS has been "not proving anything". And the only time that would be is BEFORE November, which would only be possible if you were someone else.

and I told you I have been here a month GS has not been away that long Whirly laughed at him in here a couple of weeks ago I remember seeing it.