Frank Miller's Sin City (Recut & Extended Edition) (2005)

Started by Nevermind3 pages
Originally posted by Mando
You can read the book anywhere. You can't watch the DVD anywhere.

Unless you have a portable DVD player. 😬

Originally posted by Cinemaddiction
It's because movies like that aren't intended for wide audiences, but in this case, it somewhat backfired.

Your totally right, but in most cases I saw people who totally didn't get it. Like one dude I know saw the trailer and said something along the lines of "I don't want to see that, looks like old sh*t" and my favourite quote "Looks like a scary movie" on the bases of it being black and white. Go wonder 🙄

Originally posted by Nevermind
Unless you have a portable DVD player. 😬

😆

Allow me to rephrase.

Books Don't run on batteries.

The graphic books cost £12 each where I am, so paying £13 for the new dvd edition AND a graphic book is fab for me anyway.

Well, why read Fight Club if you have the movie? Why read The Princess Bride when you have the movie? The Sin City graphic novels have fantastic artwork. The Hard Goodbye is a great read.

If you don't like comics, that's another story.

I wanted that Book, Beacause I Wanted to know where the movie came from.

Often i would read the book BEFORE watching the movie, beacsue i want to know what it was based on, what they edited / made different.

Like Jurassic Park, that pissed me off after finishing the book. (Dispite the fact that JP was my favorit movie from when iw as 4 - 8)

For Example Lex is Younger Then Tim and Grant Loves Children.

i wonder how long it'll be before this actually hits Aus, i looked yesterday, they only have the crap bare bones disk everywhere. dammit!

Originally posted by tabby999
i wonder how long it'll be before this actually hits Aus, i looked yesterday, they only have the crap bare bones disk everywhere. dammit!

I definitely wouldn't be holding my breath.

The new DVD of Sin City is great for fans of the comic, like me, and comic readers alike. The recut/extended versions offer all 4 stories to be watched separatley like Frank Miller envisioned, instead all 4 storied being intertwined together a la Pulp Fiction. The special features are good, but nothing special. The features they could have flushed down the crapper are Robert Rodriguez teaching us how to make "Sin City Tacos", and Bruce Willis on stage trying his hardest to sing the blues. Like HE, of all people, has anything to be blue about in the first place. I, personally, like that the DVD to comes with both the theatrical and the recut/extended versions, and that the special features are worth watching. Although I already own all of the original Dark Horse issues of Sin City, I think that the included TPB of "The Hard Goodbye" will give people a good look at Miller's vision, and a chance to read a damn fine comic. I still think that $30+ is a little too much, though.

Bought it last night, I'll be watching it later.

Ordered it today 👆

where did you order it through?

Originally posted by tabby999
where did you order it through?

I got mine through Amazon.

pricy?

I'm glad I pre ordered mine, the same place is now selling the same dvd for £21/$36 dollars!

Originally posted by Nevermind
Your totally right, but in most cases I saw people who totally didn't get it. Like one dude I know saw the trailer and said something along the lines of "I don't want to see that, looks like old sh*t" and my favourite quote "Looks like a scary movie" on the bases of it being black and white. Go wonder 🙄

oh yes. my mother said it looks like something scary. then i finally got her to watch it and she said"i know u don't have me watching this dick tracy looking movie.

my barber said she grew up on stuff like this and would not want to see this

Originally posted by tabby999
pricy?

Well I got it for like $24.99 (USD) is that pricey for you? That's probably the most expensive DVD I'll own considering I get all my DVDs for basically under $20. I couldn't (nor would I) stand to have the next-to-nothing version and I think this was a worthy purchase.

I saw one for $60 f*cking bucks! It was packaged with Sin City cards and like 10 Sin City poker chips. Thats not even enough to play poker and they wanted that much more for it.

Originally posted by Myth
I saw one for $60 f*cking bucks! It was packaged with Sin City cards and like 10 Sin City poker chips. Thats not even enough to play poker and they wanted that much more for it.

What does gambling have to do with Sin City? 🤨

What a gorgeous DVD! I love how this extended edition. The comic book is a great bonus and worth smacking a few extra dollars for it. I also like what Rodriguez did to disc 2. All the stories can be watch in the order you like. This DVD is just a good as the Cannibal Holocaust 25th anniversary edition. Pure kick ass!