Who thinks fawkes is a horcrux??

Okay me and my friends made up a theory that fawkes may be a horcrux because when he flew into the chamber of secrets LV didn't try to kill him! And when the basilisk tried to kill him LV told him not to..Doesn't it all make sense ??

Please post your opinions!🙂

maybe... I don't know, there are so many theorys know, I don't know

I just remembered that you can't destroy fawkes, because dosen't he like bust into fire again and is reborned again

from the ashes, reborn.

in that case discard and spread out the ashes

Fawkes can't be a Horcrux because:
- he would be part of Voldemorts soul
- you can't make "people" a Horcrux
- if Fawkes was a Horcrux Voldemort would already be immortal and we know that he isn't.

phoenixes arent immortal. If u cut it's head off it wont jsut burst into flames and be reborn. And if it does, you can cut it into little pieces, cook it and say it's a turkey

lol true.

Originally posted by Borbarad
Fawkes can't be a Horcrux because:
- he would be part of Voldemorts soul
- you can't make "people" a Horcrux
- if Fawkes was a Horcrux Voldemort would already be immortal and we know that he isn't.

i think she means that fawkes is DD's horcrux(i think)

Originally posted by scurran
i think she means that fawkes is DD's horcrux(i think)

DD wouldn't kill anyone..

I think it's possible that fawkes is a horcrux of voldie, cause the feather in his wand is from fawkes.

Edit: fawkes isn't dd's bird?

well i still reckon harry potters scar is the horcrux

i mean all the crap he goes through with it has to do with sumthin

Originally posted by daeri
DD wouldn't kill anyone..

I think it's possible that fawkes is a horcrux of voldie, cause the feather in his wand is from fawkes.

Edit: fawkes isn't dd's bird?

fawkes dose belong to DD, the theory about DD and if he has a horcrux:he could have killed some one when he was young(lets not foget he is 150 years old!), he strongly opposes horcruxes that could mean that he regretts making one

these are just two of the points, there is a few more

Originally posted by Hollypoo
Okay me and my friends made up a theory that fawkes may be a horcrux because when he flew into the chamber of secrets LV didn't try to kill him! And when the basilisk tried to kill him LV told him not to..Doesn't it all make sense ??
Please post your opinions!🙂

No. Voldemort would have known there was no point in killing the pheonix because it would just come back to life. besides, it would be hard to hit a pheonix with a stupid little killer spell

Originally posted by Council#13
No. Voldemort would have known there was no point in killing the pheonix because it would just come back to life. besides, it would be hard to hit a pheonix with a stupid little killer spell

but it happend tough, in OOTP

Spoiler:
I thought Fawkes died with Dumbledore at the end of Half-blood Prince.

Originally posted by scurran
but it happend tough, in OOTP

Because he ate the damn spell so Dumbledore wouldn't get hit.

how would fawkes be a horcrux? Who has Voldy killed around fawkes. Think wiht your heads ppl.

Originally posted by scurran
but it happend tough, in OOTP

u gotta remember the little frog cards cuz ont hose it says DD defeated the dark wozard something... so he killed someone right... he could have used that to make horcrux or u don't know that there isn't another way to become immortal

Riddle not killed Fawkes in Chamber of Secrets doesn't mean anything since he had only created one Horcrux then, and had no knowledge of future horcruxes.

where does everyone get this crud?
-DD is not 150 years old
-Harry and his scar are both un-horcruses(not a word). You can't "accidentally" make a horcrux
-If Harry n his scar were horcruxes, why would voldy try n kill him all the time
-Why would DD make a horcrux, he is against it.
-If DD pulls a gandalf, i will never respect JKR as a writer ever again.