X-men 3 Vs Superman Returns

Started by SnakeEyes9 pages

After X3 let me down quite a bit, I'm gonna have to say Superman Returns was the better film, in my opinion.

Originally posted by roughrider
What are we fighting for? 🙄

You claim the majority of people here think Superman Returns is a better movie than X3. Perhaps you're not being accurate, or premature - the film has only been out for five days now. I just pointed to the poll above as a sign that your opinion isn't accurate. You want to start a new thread about what is the best comic film this year, go ahead.

I'm going to assume more people here like Superman Returns slightly better or more than X3.

The poll has nothing to do with disproving that assumption, is the point I'm making.

You know what happens when you 'assume', right?

I seen them both. Both had good action sequences and pretty neat CGI. However the edge goes to the Icon of Comic Books...

...Superman Returns

I praise DC comics and Bryan Singer for giving a great film. I do have however some negatives about the film but still...it tops Xmen...any Xmen movie....In FACT! It tops ANY Marvel Comics movie based on a character (with the exception of Conan The Barbarian)

WHAT???!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!!!?!?!? i hate you and superman

does xmen 3 count as a movie or just a really bad joke let out on a grand scale?

superman for the win, hell 1978 superman is better than the xmen series....

x3 was kind of a letdown after the first two xmen movies. singer did an awesome job on superman returns! i was suprised coz i was expecting more from x3 and less from superman

SR only because of the spidey trailer. 🙂 Yes. I see the preveiw and leave. I don't like skinny superman... ew.
X3 was hotness. Hands down. Pyro vs. Iceman sceene... 👆