DE Palpatine and DE Luke vs. ROTS Yoda and ROTS Mace

The reborn Dark Lord and his powerful new apprentice are confronted by Jedi Masters Yoda and Mace Windu on the bridge of the Eclipse.

Dark team wins, definitely.

Sidious was a match for both Jedi Masters during ROTS times. In DE, he'd curbstomp them.

I agree. DE Sidious could take on Yoda or Mace and annihilate either of them. With Luke, it's merely overkill.

Dark Team wins, but doesn't pwn them.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Dark Team wins, but doesn't pwn them.

Yes. If Exar Kun could pwn Yoda or Mace, so could DE Sidious. He would crush either of them. So let's say if Mace kills DE Luke, by that time, Yoda would be dead - and Mace would be, borrowing Ianus's phrase, "saber-raped".

DE Sidious lost to JA Luke and JA Leia. He isn't as uber as you are making him out to be. What else does he have other than transporting Luke across the galaxy. He also made the force storms, but Luke and Leia were able to overpower those and make him lose control of them, destroying the Eclipse. Since Leia did like nothing(since she is still weaker than a weak Jedi Knight even 20 years after DE), Luke must have done most of the work. Yoda is probably at least as good as DE Luke. Therefor, DE guys win, but not by a ton.

Yoda is almost as good as DE Luke?

That's a scary thought there.

If you are refering to my post, I said at least as good.

Originally posted by Escape81
Yes. If Exar Kun could pwn Yoda or Mace, so could DE Sidious. He would crush either of them. So let's say if Mace kills DE Luke, by that time, Yoda would be dead - and Mace would be, borrowing Ianus's phrase, "saber-raped".

Just out of curiosity, how is DE Sidious suddenly leagues upon leagues above Yoda in dueling ability? Admittedly, he'd decimate him from a range with Force powers, but at sword-range? I think he's improved enough to take out Yoda in saber-combat, but not enough to 'saber-rape' him. And would he be able to do so before Luke falls to Mace?

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
If you are refering to my post, I said at least as good.

Yes, I see that. Just a scary thought that Luke became nearly as good or possibly better than Yoda in a few short years. Totally ridiculous, even.

Well, by now he has a decade of training in the force, along with the Kaiburr Crystal, and the big find, an small sized Jedi Library to learn from.

Originally posted by Ianus
Yes, I see that. Just a scary thought that Luke became nearly as good or possibly better than Yoda in a few short years. Totally ridiculous, even.

He isn't, really. Luke at this point is very good, granted. But I highly doubt that he can threaten either of these two Jedi Masters at this point.

Yeah, I don't think DE Luke was that good, either.

I don't want to sound like I'm downgrading him. I've recently begun to find him intriguing. But realistically, I don't see him threatening these two. Mace alone has more than forty years of experience on Luke, and Yoda -- well, I don't need to go into that.

Yeah. And didn't DE Luke submit to Sidious because he knew he couldn't defeat him initially or something?

Yep. He knew that Palpatine was far too powerful to defeat, so he joined him to learn the source of his power, to defeat him from within. Just like Quinlan Vos did with Dooku. But both of them almost fell to the temptations of the Dark Side, and it took someone very close to bring them back.

Off topic, but I've heard that Vos's "wife", Khaleen, may have given birth to Mara Jade. That would be interesting.

Where'd you hear this? I heard she was one of Nejaa's kids or something.

Corran is Nejaa's son, I think. Maybe his great uncle.

I personally thought Mara was Vima's daughter.

No, Glentract's right. I heard it was Vima's daughter. Not sure why Nejaa popped in my mind.

Wikicities does state Vos as possbile though, since there is nothing canon on it. Vima does seem the most likely to me though.