Elektra vs. Lady Shiva

Started by jinzin3 pages

elektra

Elektra wins. She has impressive speed feats and I rate her physical stats over Shiva's. However skill wise I think Shiva edges out Elektra.

In DCU, Shiva is always been the top 2 best on it's earth. Elektra is a probable top 5 in marvel earth. In pure h2h Shiva 6/10. With mind tricks, Elektra 5.5/10

Shiva 5.5/10

Originally posted by joesha28
In DCU, Shiva is always been the top 2 best on it's earth.
So it goes KK then Shiva?

Originally posted by joesha28
Elektra is a probable top 5 in marvel earth.

yeah, but those top 5 are all > Shiva so this is a bum argument from the start. 😕

Elektra is faster, JUST as skilled, just as ruthless, more durable and has jedi mind tricks she takes a solid 7-8. Without jedi powers, she still takes a solid 6.

Originally posted by joesha28
In DCU, Shiva is always been the top 2 best on it's earth. Elektra is a probable top 5 in marvel earth. In pure h2h Shiva 6/10. With mind tricks, Elektra 5.5/10

It seems White Canary is above Shiva. And would be a better fight for Elektra.

This woman.... 🙂

Top 5 martial artists in the MU are obviously above Shiva since their cosmic characters and no Elektra isn't one of them.

Even if you go by people who are on earth shes still not that high especially considering her recent fight with black widow.

Originally posted by SasuOna
Top 5 martial artists in the MU are obviously above Shiva since their cosmic characters and no Elektra isn't one of them.

Even if you go by people who are on earth shes still not that high especially considering her recent fight with black widow.

Which recent title and issue did Elektra fight Black Widow? Would like to see it. I think I'll stile side with Elektra on this one because of overall record.

Originally posted by SasuOna
considering her recent fight with black widow.

everyone has low showings,

It wasn't even that. Elektra was talking it out with BW trying to figure out why she was being spied on. It was practically a sparring match.

Originally posted by jinzin
It wasn't even that. Elektra was talking it out with BW trying to figure out why she was being spied on. It was practically a sparring match.

According to Sas it was an indication of Elektras failings as one of the most formidable earth bound MAs in Marvels mainstream, but meh.

Originally posted by Juk3n
everyone has low showings,

Elektra's low showings is Black Widow stalemating her in what was essentially a spar for information. Shiva's are losing to Tim Drake in spar and Huntress stalemating her in an exhibition match. What's worse?

Originally posted by Juk3n
According to Sas it was an indication of Elektras failings as one of the most formidable earth bound MAs in Marvels mainstream, but meh.

Well, Sas says a lot of things. 😎

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Elektra's low showings is Black Widow stalemating her in what was essentially a spar for information. Shiva's are losing to Tim Drake in spar and Huntress stalemating her in an exhibition match. What's worse?
hmm.. hard to say.. i mean Robin had a whistle that is a game changer right there.

Shiva.

Originally posted by King Castle
hmm.. hard to say.. i mean Robin had a whistle that is a game changer right there.

Rape whistle?

Originally posted by jinzin
Rape whistle?
robin attached a whistle to his bo staff to distract Shiva whenever he moved his staff 😆

distracting her to get the upper hand in the sparring match

Tim beating Shiva while she was poisoned is a good gauge of her skill?

Originally posted by SasuOna
Tim beating Shiva while she was poisoned is a good gauge of her skill?

That isn't the example we are talking about... 😉