hulk w/wolverine's claws v captain america's shield

Started by Dark Urizen5 pages
Originally posted by long pig
There isn't any Adamantium in the shield.

It's not Adamantium inside of it per se, but seeing as how Adamantium was developed as a faulted attempt to reproduce the process of creating his shield, i just mentioned that it exists in the shield.

Originally posted by Dark Urizen
It's not Adamantium inside of it per se, but seeing as how Adamantium was developed as a faulted attempt to reproduce the process of creating his shield, i just mentioned that it exists in the shield.

"...chance mixture of iron, vibranium and an unknown catalyst. The alloy was indestructible, yet the shield was light enough to use as a discus-like weapon that could be angled to return to him. (In several stories, due to writer error, the shield was described as an adamantium-vibranium alloy." - Wikipedia

I guess it doesn't contain adamantium. It has some iron, vibranium and something else. Guess there's no way to know which is stronger.

Originally posted by scotsmn
"...chance mixture of iron, vibranium and an unknown catalyst. The alloy was indestructible, yet the shield was light enough to use as a discus-like weapon that could be angled to return to him. (In several stories, due to writer error, the shield was described as an adamantium-vibranium alloy." - Wikipedia

I guess it doesn't contain adamantium. It has some iron, vibranium and something else. Guess there's no way to know which is stronger.

the "writer's error" was him thinking logically, that since the process of trying to recreate Cap's shield lead to the creation of adamantium, it would contain some.

As for which is stronger, didn't that demon with the weird name from Limbo break his claws and use them as toothpicks? And he was just a class 100 guy.

Cap's shield's only been hurt AFAIK by KT's Mjolnir.

Cap's shield>>>Adamantium

Originally posted by Dark Urizen

As for which is stronger, didn't that demon with the weird name from Limbo break his claws and use them as toothpicks? And he was just a class 100 guy.

Hmm? What are you talking about? No demon has broken his claws. Are you talking about something other than 616?

Originally posted by scotsmn
Hmm? What are you talking about? No demon has broken his claws. Are you talking about something other than 616?

New Mutants (1st series) # 73

S'ym is the guy to do it.

Originally posted by Dark Urizen
New Mutants (1st series) # 73

S'ym is the guy to do it.

😄 Wolverine isn't dead. That's not valid. Alternate realities and such are not useable evidence.

Originally posted by scotsmn
😄 Wolverine isn't dead. That's not valid. Alternate realities and such are not useable evidence.

🤨 It's in continuity, when Illyana transported them to Limbo. It's as valid as it comes.

Originally posted by Dark Urizen
🤨 It's in continuity, when Illyana transported them to Limbo. It's as valid as it comes.

Nah man, not useable. Limbo? You gotta be kidding me. Laws are completely different in Limbo.

Not really. Nothing was different.

S'ym breaking adamantium is canon.

Originally posted by scotsmn
Nah man, not useable. Limbo? You gotta be kidding me. Laws are completely different in Limbo.

Same Wolverine, same adamantium, same S'ym, continuity. No way to wiggle your way out of that 😂

Originally posted by Dark Urizen
Same Wolverine, same adamantium, same S'ym, continuity. No way to wiggle your way out of that 😂

ubt...wolbereen wnis...??

How is it canon if Wolverine is not dead? 😆 You have no way of even proving that it was Wolverine's skeleton he snapped. Did Wolverine magically come back to life and sew his claw back on? 🙄

Did Wolverine magically come back to life

Yes, yes he indeed did. Like a few pages later.

Originally posted by long pig
Yes, yes he indeed did. Like a few pages later.

O'RLY? And he welded his adamantium claw back on as well? 😱

Originally posted by scotsmn
O'RLY? And he welded his amantium claw back on as well? 😱

It magically welded itself.

Originally posted by long pig
It magically welded itself.

That's what I thought 😂

Originally posted by scotsmn
That's what I thought 😂

No, seriously.

Originally posted by long pig
No, seriously.

Almost as if... it never... happened?! ✅

Things that happen in alternate dimensions have no bearing on what is possible in our dimension.

Sure it does.