Character Ownage

Started by -Pr-5,121 pages

Originally posted by The Sorrow
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/13204089/19.jpg.html

^
So Hulk takes on one half of the PF while Xavier, Scarlett Witch, Iceman, Cap, Thor, Magneto etc takes on the other 😂

What about Ms. Marvel?

Originally posted by The Sorrow
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/13204089/19.jpg.html

^
So Hulk takes on one half of the PF while Xavier, Scarlett Witch, Iceman, Cap, Thor, Magneto etc takes on the other 😂


It's difficult to process how much of an atrocity the whole Phoenix Force avatar business has become in AvX.

I'm still sticking to my idea that none of the avatars have anything more than a fraction of a percentage of an iota of the PF. That the actual "bird" has not been "divided" amongst them.

Like with Surfer and the Power Cosmic, he has enough of it to be a fearsome Herald, but he is not the manifestation of the PC in its totality.

I just cannot imagine a Galactus challenging force can be poured into 5 beings and then said beings can be 1) scared of Rulk and 2) engaged by Hulk.

I know I say the HulkForce is a universal force but, until Marvel actually make that explicit, this shouldn't really happen.

Not to say that he should be KOed like Thor, no, Hulk is clearly orders of magnitude more powerful now but still ... not challenging a fraction of the PF.

BTW, the fight with Phoerost isn't apparently going on at the same time as the astral dinner date with Scott, so she's not really all that engaged with Hulk at all.

Originally posted by -Pr-
What about Ms. Marvel?

Clearly she's being blown-away by the shockwave from Hulk's attack (happens all the time to heralds).

Originally posted by janus77
Clearly she's being blown-away by the shockwave from Hulk's attack (happens all the time to heralds).

I suppose you could see it that way. shrug

To me it looked like Emma blasted her away.

Originally posted by -Pr-
What about Ms. Marvel?

Haven't a clue what's going on with her in that scan. She looks neither here nor there.

Also is that "blood" coming out of her nose in the last panel?

Originally posted by janus77
It's difficult to process how much of an atrocity the whole Phoenix Force avatar business has become in AvX.

I'm still sticking to my idea that none of the avatars have anything more than a fraction of a percentage of an iota of the PF. That the actual "bird" has not been "divided" amongst them.

Like with Surfer and the Power Cosmic, he has enough of it to be a fearsome Herald, but he is not the manifestation of the PC in its totality.

I just cannot imagine a Galactus challenging force can be poured into 5 beings and then said beings can be 1) scared of Rulk and 2) engaged by Hulk.

I know I say the HulkForce is a universal force but, until Marvel actually make that explicit, this shouldn't really happen.

Not to say that he should be KOed like Thor, no, Hulk is clearly orders of magnitude more powerful now but still ... not challenging a fraction of the PF.

BTW, the fight with Phoerost isn't apparently going on at the same time as the astral dinner date with Scott, so she's not really all that engaged with Hulk at all.


Then your notion is completely wrong .

Btw , Sinister correctly assessed the fact that those five are substandard hosts in a previous Uncanny issue .

Anyways even if you have the full PF , you can still be beaten by beings far less powerful than you if you aren't acclimatized to the power . PF-Rachel's performance against Thor is proof of that .

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Haven't a clue what's going on with her in that scan. She looks neither here nor there.

Also is that "blood" coming out of her nose in the last panel?

Don't know. Could be.

Originally posted by -Pr-
What about Ms. Marvel?

What about Storm? She's abstract, you know

Originally posted by Cogito
What about Storm? She's abstract, you know

lawl.

Never understood the Storm wanking...

^ I think it has to do with boobs and lonely male readers

Originally posted by Cogito
^ I think it has to do with boobs and lonely male readers

Originally posted by janus77
It's difficult to process how much of an atrocity the whole Phoenix Force avatar business has become in AvX.

I'm still sticking to my idea that none of the avatars have anything more than a fraction of a percentage of an iota of the PF. That the actual "bird" has not been "divided" amongst them.

Like with Surfer and the Power Cosmic, he has enough of it to be a fearsome Herald, but he is not the manifestation of the PC in its totality.

I just cannot imagine a Galactus challenging force can be poured into 5 beings and then said beings can be 1) scared of Rulk and 2) engaged by Hulk.

I know I say the HulkForce is a universal force but, until Marvel actually make that explicit, this shouldn't really happen.

Not to say that he should be KOed like Thor, no, Hulk is clearly orders of magnitude more powerful now but still ... not challenging a fraction of the PF.

BTW, the fight with Phoerost isn't apparently going on at the same time as the astral dinner date with Scott, so she's not really all that engaged with Hulk at all.

If you don't believe that the entire entity was divided among those 5 members then where is the rest of the bird then?

And no they weren't scared of Rulk. Where did you get that from? Emma basically toyed with him until Scott blasted the shit out of him in the Avengers tie in.

Hulks performance in AvX 11 is justified because it has to correspond with Cap seeking out his help as somewhat of a last resort. It wouldn't make much sense for Cap to make such a dramatic speech toward Hulk along these lines, then turn around and have him 1 shot or beat with ease albeit it's within Emmas capabilities to do so. That's what I got from it.

BTW this was Savage Hulk am I right?

Originally posted by Sundipped
If you don't believe that the entire entity was divided among those 5 members then where is the test of the bird then?

And no they weren't scared of Rulk. Where did you get that from? Emma basically toyed with him until Scott blasted the shit out of him in the Avengers tie in.

Hulks performance in AvX 11 is justified because it has to correspond to Cap seeking out his help as somewhat of a last resort. It wouldn't make much sense for Cap to make such a dramatic speech toward Hulk along these lines, then turn around and have him 1 shot or beat with ease albeit it's within Emmas capabilities to do so. That's what I got from it.

BTW this was Savage Hulk am I right?


imo the PF isn't actually being fully manifest in the avatars. Sinister says they're not adequate hosts, but the result is the same. The avatars are not a true depiction of what 1/5, 1/4, 1/3, 1/2... of the PF is capable of.

And yes, I accept the story depiction, I just don't see it as Hulk going toe-to-toe with the 1/2 PF.

Also Emma was, if not scared, atleast somewhat intimidated by Rulk. She was reading his mind and saying that he was a dangerous foe and that they needed to get rid of him quickly.

AvX Hulk talks a little like Savage Hulk, but far calmer and without the anger. I don't think he's operating at anywhere near Savage Hulk levels though.

Even in Avengers Assemble, he's just orders of magnitude more powerful and durable than Thor, whereas Savage Hulk was always >= Thor.

It seems more like a happy/calm "innocent" Hulk. Not the dangerous instant annihilation WBH or the smart and powerful Green Scar but definitely not as primitive as Savage Hulk.

^^She saw the Loebforce shenanigans(Rulk beating Surfer , a Watcher etc.) in his mind and that somewhat unnerved her .

Don't really understand why it should have , since he's not supposed to have/operate those powers anymore .

Originally posted by janus77
imo the PF isn't actually being fully manifest in the avatars. Sinister says they're not adequate hosts, but the result is the same. The avatars are not a true depiction of what 1/5, 1/4, 1/3, 1/2... of the PF is capable of.

And yes, I accept the story depiction, I just don't see it as Hulk going toe-to-toe with the 1/2 PF.

Also Emma was, if not scared, atleast somewhat intimidated by Rulk. She was reading his mind and saying that he was a dangerous foe and that they needed to get rid of him quickly.

AvX Hulk talks a little like Savage Hulk, but far calmer and without the anger. I don't think he's operating at anywhere near Savage Hulk levels though.

Even in Avengers Assemble, he's just orders of magnitude more powerful and durable than Thor, whereas Savage Hulk was always >= Thor.

It seems more like a happy/calm "innocent" Hulk. Not the dangerous instant annihilation WBH or the smart and powerful Green Scar but definitely not as primitive as Savage Hulk.


I'm pretty sure Cyke and Emma actually stated they were holding back, the avatars have said several times they could destroy the planet but that wasn't their goal.

It's impressive on Hulk's part, he seems to have found his niche these days he's been a beast for the last few years, especially since Paks work and more recently his role in Avengers movie. He was treated with respect in his AvX appearance, similar thing in the Avengers Assemble series.

According to one or two folk at Marvel apparently something is going to happen to Hulk at the end of Aaron's run which causes a change in him hence the dumb speech.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
According to one or two folk at Marvel apparently something is going to happen to Hulk at the end of Aaron's run which causes a change in him hence the dumb speech.

He's going to run for office? 😕

I really hope they aren't going to reset him to Savage Hulk. That whole "puny Banner!"/"Oh woe is me, what shall I do about this burden I have?" business was a dull pain, after a while.

They made wonderful progress with the character, with the meditation, the fleshing out of "The Hulk persona" and also with the growth of Banner into a legit fully functional genius.

I'd hate to see all that lost because they want to do something dramatic and new.

Originally posted by janus77
He's going to run for office? 😕

I really hope they aren't going to reset him to Savage Hulk. That whole "puny Banner!"/"Oh woe is me, what shall I do about this burden I have?" business was a dull pain, after a while.

They made wonderful progress with the character, with the meditation, the fleshing out of "The Hulk persona" and also with the growth of Banner into a legit fully functional genius.

I'd hate to see all that lost because they want to do something dramatic and new.


Personally I didn't like the new, cunning, cold Banner who suddenly was one of Marvels top inventors.

Originally posted by janus77
He's going to run for office? 😕

I really hope they aren't going to reset him to Savage Hulk. That whole "puny Banner!"/"Oh woe is me, what shall I do about this burden I have?" business was a dull pain, after a while.

They made wonderful progress with the character, with the meditation, the fleshing out of "The Hulk persona" and also with the growth of Banner into a legit fully functional genius.

I'd hate to see all that lost because they want to do something dramatic and new.


Who knows, the messed up continuity doesn't help either, they have two books out in which he is dumb and another in which he's become the smart "Merged Hulk" again.

On topic, Victor owns Banner in typical Doom fashion: http://doktorvondoom.tumblr.com/image/31470545054

Originally posted by janus77
imo the PF isn't actually being fully manifest in the avatars. Sinister says they're not adequate hosts, but the result is the same. The avatars are not a true depiction of what 1/5, 1/4, 1/3, 1/2... of the PF is capable of.

Exactly. A sliver of the PF that Necrom had that he couldn't even access unless Rachel was accessing her power, was doing this :
Originally posted by id369
[B]Excalibur volume 1, issue #50
Rachael vs Necrom. Battle wise, good showings.
Asteroids, and moons are thrown at each other. Planetes are one shotted, and ignited to form a sun. Devastation to an entire Solar System.
http://img45.imageshack.us/img45/2465/050p22ya5.jpg
http://img215.imageshack.us/img215/9704/050p23ww5.jpg
http://img215.imageshack.us/img215/1142/050p24hy7.jpg
http://img263.imageshack.us/img263/6325/050p25rw7.jpg
http://img524.imageshack.us/img524/2493/050p26eh6.jpg
http://img215.imageshack.us/img215/2250/050p27tn6.jpg
http://img118.imageshack.us/img118/9195/050p28zo7.jpg
http://img118.imageshack.us/img118/8331/050p29gp6.jpg
http://img524.imageshack.us/img524/5117/050p30ux5.jpg
http://img248.imageshack.us/img248/4034/050p31mk6.jpg [/B]

And look here, Mastermind accessing Rachel's power achieving Universal Cosmic Awareness and oneness with the Universe :

The P5 don't even seem to have Rachel level PF powers.