I think Wolverine is the better tracker of the two. Daredevil can find someone, but I'm pretty sure he can only detect something within reasonable ranges (comparable to line-of-sight). Wolverine can smell you from miles away, and even if he can't, he can track the scent of a trail that someone left behind, and find someone that way. Wolverine's one of the most skilled trackers in the Marvel Universe. I'm pretty sure he takes this with ease.
Originally posted by Melnorme
I think Wolverine is the better tracker of the two. Daredevil can find someone, but I'm pretty sure he can only detect something within reasonable ranges (comparable to line-of-sight). Wolverine can smell you from miles away, and even if he can't, he can track the scent of a trail that someone left behind, and find someone that way. Wolverine's one of the most skilled trackers in the Marvel Universe. I'm pretty sure he takes this with ease.
Ok, when has Wolverine smelled someone from miles away? And i don't meen TRACKED someone for miles.
I mean like he's somewhere and someone is miles away. And he goes "Hey, X is n miles away". Because if X was where Wolverine is now and Wolverine is just sniffing and saying "X was here and he headed in that direction", and at the same time X is reaching n miles from where Wolverine is, then Daredevil could do the same thing just as easily 😬
Originally posted by Dark Urizen
DD can lock onto the person's heartbeat. Each heartbeat has certain....irregularities.
Originally posted by Dark Urizen
Ok, when has Wolverine smelled someone from miles away? And i don't meen TRACKED someone for miles.
I mean like he's somewhere and someone is miles away. And he goes "Hey, X is n miles away". Because if X was where Wolverine is now and Wolverine is just sniffing and saying "X was here and he headed in that direction", and at the same time X is reaching n miles from where Wolverine is, then Daredevil could do the same thing just as easily 😬
I'm not certain he can. He may be able to...off the top of my head Ultimate Wolverine was able to scent where his legs landed after the Hulk tossed `em, so it doesn't seem too out of the question.
But even if he cannot, he can scent a trail left behind by someone. A bloodhound can, and say what you will, but Wolverine is almost certainly as perceptive and probably less easily fooled than a bloodhound.
Originally posted by Melnorme
I'm sorry, but that's not the case. Unless a heart has an "irregularity", it sounds just like every other heart out there. Why would doctors even bother listening to your heartbeat if no two sounded alike?
Because these are comic book characters who live in a world where a giant purple armored man in a skirt goes around eating planets 😉
Originally posted by Jose123
Because these are comic book characters who live in a world where a giant purple armored man in a skirt goes around eating planets 😉
If there's no basis in anything remotely resembling our reality, then why do we even try to compare? Everything is magical and unknowable, in that case.
Originally posted by Melnorme
I'm sorry, but that's not the case. Unless a heart has an "irregularity", it sounds just like every other heart out there. Why would doctors even bother listening to your heartbeat if no two sounded alike?
They all function the same way. Asking why doctors would bother listening to your heartbeat sounds like "Why would a computer repairman even look at your CPU, cause all CPUs are the same". Which....they're not.
There are a few heart conditions that everybody suffers from, like chronic vitamin deficiency, which lead to almost unnoticeable differences in how the heart....well.....beats 😛
Originally posted by Melnorme
Are you certain he's recognizing them by heartbeat alone, and not other factors, like breathing, scent, height, sound of their walk, etc? I think you'd have a hell of time proving it.
in one issue he specifically states
"A girl...No more than sixteen judging by her heartbeat and a baby maybe two months old or so"
This was all while he was in a confessional a couple of blocks away
then later in the same issue
"There are those dual heart signatures again the girl and the baby from this morning"
this was while he was working at his law firm.
Can't scan it but their in Marvel Knights Daredevil issue 1 page 7 and page 13
Originally posted by Jose123
in one issue he specifically states"A girl...No more than sixteen judging by her heartbeat and a baby maybe two months old or so"
This was all while he was in a confessional a couple of blocks away
then later in the same issue
"There are those dual heart signatures again the girl and the baby from this morning"
this was while he was working at his law firm.
Can't scan it but their in Marvel Knights Daredevil issue 1 page 7 and page 13
✅
Originally posted by Jose123
He has other senses to you know.
What stopping him from sniffing his way just like wolverine. If all his other senses were heightened to such superhuman quality why wouldn't his smell be enhanced as well.And he has legs you know he can walk until he hears his target or pick up his scent.
again his sens eof smell is not as greta as wolverine nor is his stamina
Originally posted by wolverine8888
again his sens eof smell is not as greta as wolverine nor is his stamina
Ahem
Originally posted by soleran30
actually tracking somone across a country isn't done by scent its done through investigative work and the ability to use his senses allows wolverine to augment that ability.
like I said If Wolverine can do it than DD should be a natural at it
Originally posted by Jose123
Ahemlike I said If Wolverine can do it than DD should be a natural at it
again it was ****ign stated that wolverien sense of smell is greater then DD. also don't even try to say DD stamina would be any were near to close to wolverine.
again if DD is a natural at. it it hardly matters wolverine is like an animal he was more of a natural at it and has been doing it for over 100 years who gunna be better at it?