More bashing for Mr. Christensen (don't know if it's been posted)

Originally posted by Eleonora
You are denying the quintessential element that separates life forms from lifeless objects: the ability to distinguish, form an opinion and, consequently, act. Fans are not born fans, they make a choice that comes directly from the makings of the mind, so I believe this dogmatic approach towards fandom comes very close to dementia. I think that unfortunately (I mean it) we all have a different view of the world, so an objective judgement, fan or non-fan, is impossible.

Fans should just not judge.. Just don't.. ❌

Originally posted by overlord
That's all very cute but you left out prejudism and that not everybody actually goes through the trouble of judging neutrally.

Fans should just not judge.. Just don't.. ❌

No I didn't, read the last line. I said that everybody's prejudiced, not just fans, and that a neutral judgement is impossible. Why don't people read?

Originally posted by Eleonora
No I didn't, read the last line. I said that everybody's prejudiced, not just fans, and that a neutral judgement is impossible. Why don't people read?

Originally posted by overlord
You don't get what I'm saying.

Oh dear, do I detect panic?

That over analytical message wasn't appropriate to that subject anyway, what's up with that?

Yep, definitely panic. If you have nothing further to add please avoid useless and not-so-clever answers, it saves us both a lot of time. Just a thought. 😉

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
George Lucas is the only reason for Episode II's suckfullness. Even though Hayden is a douche in my opinion, he actually can act (see Shattered Glass or Life As A House), as can Natalie Portman (see anything she's been in apart from Star Wars). GL is just a terrible actor director and has dumb ideas of what he wants from his actors.

I thoroughly agree. Hayden's performances in Life as a House and Shattered Glass were awesome and Natalie was fantastic as early on as The Professional, though she was still quite young. Much as I love Star Wars, the dialogue/script has always been less than what it could have been (even in the OT).

Originally posted by Eleonora
Oh dear, do I detect panic?

Yep, definitely panic. If you have nothing further to add please avoid useless and not-so-clever answers, it saves us both a lot of time. Just a thought. 😉

As for saving time: don't forget that you don't have take me serious.

Originally posted by overlord
As for saving time: don't forget that you don't have take me serious.

How true, but I'm compassionate 🙂

Originally posted by McCusto
Seriously, and why is anyone bashing Hayden, all he did is do what George Lucas told him to do.

This is technically incorrect, George Lucas told him to act. He didn't tell him to act terriblly...