Raven vs Sidious Debate on who should rule the Galaxies
I've always been curious as to see what would if the great Sith Lords, put their lightsabers down, and debated who sould rule the galaxies. And since these 2 sith lords are some of the smartest, most cunning, and masters of debating, who would win? There is no lightsabers fighting at all. Who would talk who down?
Re: Raven vs Sidious Debate on who should rule the Galaxies
Originally posted by Itzak
I've always been curious as to see what would if the great Sith Lords, put their lightsabers down, and debated who sould rule the galaxies. And since these 2 sith lords are some of the smartest, most cunning, and masters of debating, who would win? There is no lightsabers fighting at all. Who would talk who down?
Hmm I don't know.
Revan did manipulate many jedi to go over to his side, that's pretty impressive. He was also an excellent strategist. But Sidious is also damn good, he is very manipulative and has for 13 years only discussed and manipulated people, I say he has more experience in that matter.
I'd say Sidious by a tiny margin although I'm very open to pursuation.
I have no idea... This would probably end up to be a long very boring debate where neither one of them makes any progress while trying to convince the other person.
In the end Revan will win because he's younger and can probably go without sleep longer. Seriously though what kind of a stupid thread is this? How could we ever know?
When you put a megalomaniac, sociopathic, sadistic dolt like Malak in any position of command in your near vicinity, your tactical skills lack merit. Not only that, when you get boarded and cornered like a rat by the Jedi, as well as not even having any sort of contingency plan....and this is a sadistic dolt you've likely defeated at some point in the past
Originally posted by Lightsnake
When you put a megalomaniac, sociopathic, sadistic dolt like Malak in any position of command in your near vicinity, your tactical skills lack merit. Not only that, when you get boarded and cornered like a rat by the Jedi, as well as not even having any sort of contingency plan....and this is a sadistic dolt you've likely defeated at some point in the past
Malak was hardly an idiot, he lacked commanding ability's but he wasn't needed to command the fleets, Revan had others for that including himself. Malak his main purpose was of course to fight the Jedi and the Mandelorians and when Revan was a Sith his choices on second in command were limited to Malak and well nobody else because the command structure was based on power.
Also the Jedi boarding Revan his ship, it was most likely a trap from Revan who wanted to capture Bastila the only thing that stood between him and victory.
And if you want to play it like that, Sidious let a team of people get onto Endor when he could have easily stopped them, he refused to destroy the rebel fleet when he had the chance and never once considered the possibility that he might lose, thats not very smart either. Still I don't see what this has to do with the debate these two will have, Revan is a brilliant talker and very charismatic, and you already know Sidious.
To claim that either one of them will win is nothing short of foolish.